Obviously something strange is going on with the Western projection of power in the area. I am a firm believer in the incompetence of the CIA, but surely they wouldn't accidentally let ISIS receive weapons that many times in a row? And in one month of bombing, Russia has hit 4 times as many strategic ISIS targets, than the entire Western coalition, all while supposedly being more interested in hitting moderate Syrian forces. The same moderates who always seem to funnel Western arms to ISIS.
So either there is just a tragic level of incompetence by the US, or there is something very strange going on with the US and ISIS.
Do you have a source for this? The coalition has supposedly flown more than 8,000 strikes(40,000 sorties), hit more than 16,000 targets and spent north of $5bn. I have a very, very tough time believing Russia has quadrupled this effort in the handful of months they've been flying sorties.
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-11-19/caught-tape-russian...
http://edition.cnn.com/2014/09/11/world/meast/isis-syria-ira...
This is completely arbitrary nonsense.
> And if the coalition had really hit 16,000 targets, there wouldn't be any ISIS left.
So is this. This also belies a misunderstanding of both the situation and warfare in general.
The key difference between the two parties involved here is that Russian doctrine has exactly zero considerations for collateral damage and civilians. For example, Russian news sources would have you believe one cruise missile "killed 600 terrorists".
And when you point out the "key difference" between the West and Russia, what's your point exactly? If the goal is to not hurt innocents, then the best way to do that would be to go home. The goal is to degrade ISIS's ability to wage war.
My point is that if you think the US strikes have been ineffective, is because you don't know what "effective" looks like. You want to see many bombs drop and big explosions with not thought as to what that's actually accomplishing.
It was only after the Russians started making the US look incompetent by flying more sorties in a couple of days then the US did in a month, did the US begin to start bombing in earnest.
Even laughable is PBS showing footage of Russian bombing and claiming it to be American. http://www.pbs.org/ombudsman/blogs/ombudsman/2015/11/23/bomb...
Source for this?
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2015/11/23/analysts-ac...
Anti-Hezbollah (etc...) sounds great until you realize what they want to replace it with.
I think the only real drawback to IS, in strategic terms, is if their violence spills over too much, like it happened recently, but that hasn't been, and probably still isn't, much of a real concern.
http://www.mintpressnews.com/julian-assange-us-israel-planne...
The US ambassador cable is the reflection of the long term interests which actually like the instabilities more (including the conflicts between Sunni and Shia) than the presence of Assad. BTW Assad is kind-of-Shia, and Iran full-Shia. The "rebels," Turkey, ISIS and Saudis are Sunni.
The "indirect support" is the fact that the weapons procured by the West (over Turkey) ended up by ISIS. Not to mention effectively allowing different kinds of financing ISIS.
I agree with all the estimates presented here that now with the events in Europe not everything will continue exactly as it was up to that point.
Whether they are "serious about hurting IS" seems arbitrarily defined by whoever is posing the question. What we do know is that the coalition has conducted ~40,000 sorties over the past year. That seems pretty "serious" to me, but some people might consider "serious" to only mean ground forces.
Do you know when the economic sanctions against ISIS where introduced, and when against Assad? Against ISIS, I can find the "Sept. 29, 2015." Isn't it strangely recent?
The bomb strikes are also a good way to show that "something" is done ("we must do something, this is something.") All politicians ordering them like them.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_intervention_against_...
Aside from that, you could consider the coalitions that have formed against ISIS as the "true" sanctions, in a way.
http://www.thenation.com/article/hard-look-iraq-sanctions/
Look at Iraq now. Also Libya before 2011 and afterwards. The "rebels" in Libya, supported by the West, were again at least sometimes, again "accidentally," al-Qaeda.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2610598/Group-US-swi...
Re "our rebels" in Syria: Al Nusrah wasn't on the list of the terrorist organizations before 2014. ISIS wasn't too, now it's "but we considered them under al-Qaeda."
http://m.state.gov/md123085.htm
Of course it's a mess there, but it's clear that Assad was considered as the main target. Just like Saddam before. Or Gaddafi. Civilians and all the other effects be damned.
I don't see there anything "objectively" righteous.
And this is why the "West" is getting closer to the Russian position on Syria.
And this is not good for Turkey, who want Assad gone. And this is probably why a Russian fighter was downed today. This look like an incident, but this is first and foremost a political or diplomatic statement.
I also don't think the ISIS 'spillover' is as much of a concern as indicated, at the higher echelons of Western military and intelligence circles. A cynic might say that it could even have its uses.
Holland is going to Moscow and Washington this week to request Putin's help on Syria and form a coalition. If you think that Hollande would have allowed Turkey to shot down a Russian plane today, this is basically the worst time it could have ever happened.
So I don't buy for a second that France would have supported that move, especially this week.
On the other hand, if Turkey wanted to prevent NATO getting closer to Russia, this was a perfect timing.
If the overall NATO strategy is that they need ISIS for a bit longer, then France will acquiesce, whether or not Hollande is very upset about it. But of course they will make a spectacle about 'total war', nothing short of that would be acceptable to the public.
Let ISIL overtake Syria/remove Assad and then 'free' Syria from ISIL and impose freedom.
Source are former IS fighters, sorry - its in german & paywalled: https://blendle.com/i/die-zeit/aus-sicht-der-tater/bnl-zeit-...
http://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/624/cpsprodpb/83ED/production/_...
Even if the whole IS is not always just fighting Assad, they are deep in the Assad controlled regions too (Assad is in Damascus look how near they are). A lot of "empty" area are the deserts.