ChefSteps Announces Joule
chefsteps.com
chefsteps.com
Functionally, there is almost no difference between any of the wand models on the market. I've found the features like wireless controls completely gimmicky and unnecessary. So long as the device is accurate enough and powerful enough, it will do everything you want. Grab an Anova for $100 and get started.
For a wider view of this space:
Temperature-controlled cooking "version 1" = thermostat on an oven. (A real innovation in it's own time!)
Temperature-controlled cooking "version 2" = sous-vide. (Steady-state thermal equilibrium -- that is, waiting until temperature has equalized throughout the entire mass.)
Temperature-controlled cooking "version 3" is about going beyond steady-state thermal equilibrium to controlling transient heat transfer.
That gives you the delicious repeatability of sous-vide, with the fast cooking times of non-steady-state cooking, and the controlled, desirable temperature gradients at the exterior of your food. (Note how any sous-vide recipe ends with cooking the exterior in a pan for extra deliciousness!)
We built "v3" and called it Pantelligent. Macworld just produced a video review and said, "Most importantly, the results are fantastic. I’ve made eggs, salmon, risotto, seared tuna, and steak using Pantelligent’s recipes, and everything turned out delicious. The salmon was my favorite, since the pan’s sensor made it nearly impossible for me to overcook it" [1]. TIME Magazine just called it one of the "Best Inventions of 2015" [2]. And there are plenty more press and customer reviews on our website [3].
[1] http://www.macworld.com/article/3006950/holiday/6-chef-calib...
[2] http://time.com/4115398/best-inventions-2015/item/the-pan-th...
More correctly, I'd say that many sous-vide recipes end with searing the exterior in a pan for extra deliciousness. The food is already cooked, assuming you are post-searing. This of course gives you that maillard reaction goodness.
Having said that, I took a quick look at your links. A few comments.
- Non-stick pans aren't so non-stick after a while. How does your pan hold up?
- Lightweight, non-stick pans are poor for searing. I'm guessing that I'd need a second pan for that? Related to this are those times you actually want those crispy burned on bits for a follow-on sauce of some kind.
1) Surface coating lifetime is mostly a temperature-related effect. By controlling the temperature (i.e. avoiding unintentional too-high-temp excursions), you get longer lifetime. Plus we start with a thicker/heavier cast aluminum base than you may be used to on low-end non-stick pans. This reduces hot spots and uneven thermal expansion which both contribute to relatively shorter working lifetimes of low-end cookware.
2) We get delicious browned crusts on steaks etc in roughly the 380-420 degree F surface temperature range. You get a nice controlled browned crust, rather than a fully black crust. IMHO this is way better!
The results are really delicious.
https://www.pantelligent.com/static/img/many_steaks_board.jp...
Here's a picture from J. Kenji Lopez-Alt, of various levels of steak doneness cooked sous vide with a post-bath sear:
http://www.seriouseats.com/images/2015/04/Anova-Steak-Guide-...
I know there's a lot of variables here besides just the Pantelligent versus sous vide, but there's a pretty stark contrast between the two in the kind of temperature gradient you see throughout the meat. I'm sure you can cook a delicious steak in a Pantelligent -- you can cook a delicious steak a whole lot of ways. But you're not going to be able to produce sous vide results with this thing.
Beyond the specs, what are the actual benefits?