Driving in the US is making a big comeback
vox.com
vox.com
Given the decrepit state of the US infrastructure [1], the funds will need to be gathered soon if we wish to avoid the deleterious effects of neglect.
[0]http://www.taxhistory.org/thp/readings.nsf/ArtWeb/5DDB791947... [1]http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/
If our legislators were smarter, they would have put a racheting carbon tax in when prices were high, set to be triggered by declines. Alas.
I'm asking for people who use the roads to pay their fair share; you're asking the government to collect money from everyone so the road-users can keep believing roads are self-funding. When the users are forced to confront the true cost, they'll demand better solutions.
In short: we should both cut wasteful spending and re-align the gas tax with infrastructure expenditures, because the bailout from the general fund is pork itself!
Working people already pay for the shortfall, whether they drive or not. But because the gas tax hasn't increased and the subisidy is made up out of the general budgets at the state and federal levels, the cost is hidden and alternative forms of transportation are not encouraged. [0]
[0]http://www.uspirg.org/sites/pirg/files/reports/Who%20Pays%20... (relevant pages: 6, 27)
Shifting it to the general taxpayer creates incredibly perverse incentives that are essentially indefensible. It's a level of idiocy that I'd expect from a mouth-breathing moron and/or a Microsoft employee.
High state taxes combined with federal formulation means the while oil prices are low, gas prices at the pump are still relatively high.
Relative to what? Highway user revenue accounted for approximately 48% of the total public expenditure on highways and roads in 2012. In 1970, that number was 70%. Given that the people using the roads aren't making up the cost at the pump -- not even by half -- I'd say the gas prices are very low relative to the cost of maintainence.
This has negative effects elsewhere: because we're basically subsidizing the use of cars, we're also inducing demand for roads that require federal bailouts to maintain. This, in turn, reduces the demand for more economically viable forms of transportion.
A federal gas tax is a regressive tax on urban poor to pay for rural highways. States like California take more money in on gas taxes than they spend on roads, so force states to maintain roads instead of funneling the money through Washington DC.
There are many costs associated with the use of gasoline, and the price of oil itself is a small portion of that. By this same simplification, the cost of a loaf of bread ($2.50 for 1.25 lbs) is relatively high compared to the price of wheat ($4.77 for 60lbs). But we know that there are many hidden costs to get us from wheat to bread. Add to our gasoline usage the external effects of Co2, safety, and the influence on the housing architecture -- the price of oil doesn't seem to be a particularly accurate measure of true cost.
>You are ignoring both state taxes
I ignored state tax hikes on fuel because they haven't haven't been particularly active.
• Twenty states have gone a decade or more without an increase in their gas tax rate.
• Fifteen states have gone two decades or more without a gas tax increase.
• Among the thirty-one states levying a “fixed-rate” gas tax, the average length of time since the last gas tax increase is sixteen years. [0]
>and state expenditures on roads.
State expenditure on roads is precisely what I'm attempting to draw attention to -- the states don't make enough in gas taxes, they have to spend from their general budgets and raise bonds. Several states have now reached the point where the cost of servicing debt for past projects now soaks up nearly all current revenues from gasoline taxes.[1]
>A federal gas tax is a regressive tax on urban poor to pay for rural highways.
Absolutely it is. But subsidizing the urban poor's use of cars doesn't help their situation either -- it just leads to more roads and less investment in public transportation. Public transportation is more efficient and benefits the poor and middle class, and makes roads less congested and safer for people who can afford to drive.
Additionally, mandated parking takes up valuable real estate in urban areas, driving up the cost of living. This negatives effects the working poor. [2]
>States like California take more money in on gas taxes than they spend on roads, so force states to maintain roads instead of funneling the money through Washington DC.
Current revenue from California's 42.35-cent gas tax covers only a fraction of the state's annual highway repair needs. This is why the Senate panel passed a recommendation for a 12.5 cent tax hike [3]
[0]http://www.itep.org/pdf/gastaxincreases0515.pdf
[1]http://www.uspirg.org/sites/pirg/files/reports/Who%20Pays%20... [PDF page 9]
[2]http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/10/driving-...
[3]http://www.mercurynews.com/california/ci_28668276/senate-pan...
Gas in Europe is something like twice as expensive.
Sorry about being blunt, but higher gas taxes will just hurt guys like me.
The poor and middle class need to commute. The poor and middle class can't afforded the latest energy efficient vechicles. We are tied to our old vechicles. We repair our old vechicles. The last thing we need are higher gas taxes.
I would like to see higher gas taxes, but let's tie it to income? While I'm a little tipsy, why not tie traffic fines/fees to income?
A rich man gets a traffic violation; he tells his wife over dinner.
A poor man get a traffic violation; he just might not make rent that month?
Since, I was 15.5, I never felt that was fair.
Happy thanksgiving!
Still, waiting for perfect situation isn't going to help. There's still money needed to maintain the infrastructure.
* utilize existing infrastructure (roads)
* get you 100% of the way from point A to B vs having to travel additional distance from stations
* can be gradually introduced with purchasers being those who directly benefit vs big projects dealing with nimbys, budgets, and right-of-way issues where costs-benefits aren't as aligned
* are a drop-in replacement that offer significant improvements in both safety and driver time
* open new business models of cars as service vs as product
* allow commuting from farther away, reducing housing shortages
* offer lower labor costs than buses, so cities may control their own fleets or subsidize private fleets for low income riders
... among many more benefits. Dense urban cores will still find value in subways that do not take up outdoor space, but for the most part, mid-century cities are going to be doing a lot of ripping up excess roads/lanes and parking lots, and making things both denser and greener.
http://www.notimpossiblenow.com/the-latest/google-self-drivi...
Also, the workforce is less well compensated than it was. I recall from my days in high school and college in the 90s a retail manager at the mall could afford a decent used car on their salary. Now, the car costs double and the salary is 10-20% more.
~$268 per month, four year car payment
$40,000 salary / $2,400 per month disposable income
http://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Retail_Manager/Salar...
It's only under premises such as that more driving is a good thing or that the stimulus actually worked that my statement would be partisan. I did not imply such.