† Where “headquartered” means they have a P.O. box there.
Why should it be that way?
One problem with these loopholes seems to be that it is not easy to determine where the profit is earned.
It is not that hard to determine where the income is earned provided countries share data.
Example: you're a large tech company who can afford good accountants and complicated legal structures. Your high-tax jurisdiction European subsidiaries can "license" a whole bunch of "intellectual property" from their counterparts in Ireland/Luxembourg which significantly beef up their costs to the point that net income in the high-tax jurisdiction is minimal and it all gets booked somewhere which will charge you less.
Kind of like how Apple manages its assets via a Nevada subsidiary to avoid paying tax in California, and how Microsoft does something similar with software licensing. Except at least in the US case there's still tax revenue going to the federal government.
Intellectual property is certainly a major way of avoid tax, but there are many ways of solving this. You could only allow each country to apportion IP costs on the basis of where income is earned. Alternatively, you could prevent deduction for IP licenses to entities owned by the parent company. Once you have the information of where the money goes then you can certainly tax it fairly.
It could be a sensible way to account for the fact that international companies realize huge profits in the US (big market, etc), without contributing ANYTHING to training workers, maintaining telecom, logistic infrastructure, etc.
It actually is, because that requires you to be able to easily identify which transactions are shams designed only to move the profits to a low-tax country.
Let's say the books indicate that the project required the licensure of umpteen billion dollars of IP from Luxembourg. How do you know that the U.S. branch didn't "really" need that IP (or it wasn't really produced in Lux) from only looking at the balance sheets?
> Why should it be that way?
Because the entity earning profit (person or corporation) used resources to their advantage that were paid for by the taxes in that jurisdiction.
i.e. Facebook employees drive to work on public roads, use public police, firemen and military to keep them safe, attended public elementary schools, eat food approved by the public FDA, enjoy breathable air and drinkable water governed by the public EPA, etc. etc. The list is endless.
So they're getting benefit from all those things funded by public taxes, therefore they should contribute to those taxes. If they're not paying taxes, they shouldn't be allowed to benefit from all those things.