I don't know about Windows, but on Linux... I try every so often to use other clients, but Thunderbird is still the only one I can bear.
For some reason there's always something that doesn't work with Gnome or KDE clients, keystore stuff that doesn't let me save my passwords, or seems to but doesn't actually remember them, or some indexation service insisting on taking half my CPU, or...
And the desktop-agnostic clients are ugly and lack features.
So through all this time, I've both hated Thunderbird and considered it the only usable client. I really wonder which one I'll switch to in the future.
But despite being a single-threaded, half-XML-half-C cancerous pile of dirty hacks, Thunderbird is still faster and more stable – not to mention more extensible – than Evolution could ever hope to be.
Nowadays it's self-hosting.
Also, there's an awful lot of llvm involved in compiler-rt on github.
To think you can evade C on a Unix box is very wishful thinking. You can't escape C-generated bytecode in your stack. It's bound to be somewhere.
Just look at its source, there's C everywhere.
... which is exactly what is being proposed here, with financial help from the Mozilla Foundation to ease the transition.
No encryption, no CardDav, no Sieve support. Yes, I need plugins for this in Thunderbird, but I can have them if I want to. geary is also hectic on which distribution/release is supported.
The user interface is nice though.