I think sharks are circling because people have a zeal for debunking the idea that someone is selfless. If you Google it, you can even find people who criticize Mother Theresa for having secret, selfish ulterior motives.
I personally believe people who help others always get something out of it (even if it's just private satisfaction), and that's OK. A good act is a good act, regardless of the internal thoughts that triggered it.
The subtext of the story is that the raise was an unqualified win for one person, though: Dan Price.
2 employees out of 120.
What I've seen was from Christopher Hitchens, who said that she wasn't a "good" person because her primary motivation was to proselytize, as she believed Jesus instructed her to do.
My comment was creating an analogy between those two: Dan Price doing something awesome for his employees because of a lawsuit is something like Mother Theresa serving the poor because she believed it was how she would have a good afterlife.
I don't know if either of those motivations are true. It's impossible to know someone's motivations with certainty. That's why I think an action and its consequences are the thing to focus on.
If it's true, as the article says, that Dan Price is creating the cult of Dan Price (a do-gooder-CEO kind of thing), great! Even if he's just some narcissist who wants people to love him, I'm happy that another wealthy person is pursuing some form of humanitarianism. All the really "good" people might be narcissists, for all we know!
huh? You had me up until this point.
If this experiment, of giving up a bunch of profit (and his own pay), were to succeed and make the company more profitable, it would undermine the idea that selfishness is the best way to serve yourself.
See also: enlightened self-interest[1].
Ayn Rand founded/advocated a strong, determined branch of Libertarianism called Objectivism. In an over-generalizing nutshell, it's a philosophy, often economic, of individual freedoms over community needs (a strong negative over-reaction to bad socialism).
Debates usually get hung up on Tragedy of the Commons, and whether it actually exists as a meaningful concept or whether it can always be solved via private property ownership.
The first half of the game sets up the Founder Capitalist Figure as villan, and the second half portrays him as victim to a Bootlegger/Baptist Figure. I haven't read her stuff, but I seem to recall this plot being closer to a re-enactment, based second hand descriptions of the books. The later games do a somewhat better job though.
In that light, he is absolutely buying the loyalty of his employees, and being a private company, we really have no idea how sustainable the system really is. Worse, these things are path dependent. Getting a raise from 28k->32k will feel a lot different than going from 28k->70k->32k, even though the end state is the same. This is the sort of thing that can wreck companies.
How does his motivation for giving the raises have an effect on whether this is a good way to run a business or whether it's sustainable?
And, in the context of this one issue at Gravity, it seems to have been a good move (at least what's been made public).
Pretty much every long-standing, famous CEO has done something for a personal reason (Jobs' personal vendetta against Samsung/Android for "ripping off" iOS is an example). That doesn't mean most of their decisions are personal, or that they can't run a company incredibly well.
Let me frame it this way. Let's say I was working there and thought I was getting underpaid. I started interviewing, found a job paying 65k, and was about to take it. There's some grand announcement about how everyone will get 70k and I decide, great, I'll stay. Had I been provided with what looks to be the real reason behind the raise, I may have elected to jump ship for less money.
That act alone, whatever the reason, is likely a "good" thing in that he is sacrificing his own income to help others less fortunate for himself. If there are ulterior motives, or if he has had a lifetime of bad deeds until now I'm not terribly interested.