Then I take it you don't buy into the Python philosophy of "There should be one-- and preferably only one --obvious way to do it."
When your "increment by 1" is really just in the service of iterating over a set, then the natural, obvious way should be to use a separate idiom that abstracts the concept of iteration over that set, rather than dive into the details of how you get access to the next member. Which is what Python does: "for x in ...".
If the loop is not simply iterating over the set, but tweaking some value unpredictably and periodically checking, then there's nothing special about += 1 relative to += 2.