Claim that tardigrades got 1/6 of DNA from microbes is starting to unravel
theatlantic.com
theatlantic.com
Scientists working in the same field have put out a study that disagrees with the first study. This is not a severe blow, it does not debunk the first study, it does not imply some sort of rivalry. Science is cooperative. We all want to find the truth.
Non target contamination in sequencing DNA and RNA is common. Attributing "horizontal gene transfer" due to the "noise" is a mistake. The second group actually does debunk the initial paper's main point.
Perhaps establishment science need to move the peer review from before publication to after.
The after publication 'peer review' is when colleagues attempt to replicate your findings. It's a series of gates to credibility and general acceptance, not a single door.
You'd think so, but no. Scientists want to get funded, and getting their work invalidated like this is a problem. So is making enemies among those that will review your articles in the near future.
That's why contradictions are usually softened and hidden behind praises of unrelated parts of the work - they're all in it together and they need to cooperate in order to keep getting grants. You'll usually find honest criticism in informal conversations, not published for all to see.
The fragments given the nature of the shredder are all shredded slightly at different places and they are all mixed up - so you have to piece together like a jigsaw puzzle into a single copy (genome assembly).
However suppose there are lots of palindromic repeats in the document like the phrase "stressed" repeated 100 times such that they exceed your individual 100 lettered fragment, or is it the palindrome dopleganger "desserts" repeated 100 times? Or a mix of "stressed desserts" repeated in different ways 100 times? And also what of the phrases before and after "stressed/desserts," how do you place them since you are not sure about the order/orientation of this repeat?
This is the challenge of genome assembly. Now having more copies of the shredded document helps but some repeats are very nasty and aligning them in the assembly is not statistically tractable. And also they don't necessarily encode for relevant genes so they are often filtered out. Furthermore, they are arguably the regions of the DNA that is the most prone to change, since you can think of them as the "filler text" of the document; if an important part of the document is unintelligible, then this document wouldn't survive nature's QC process of sexual selection. However, unintelligible parts of the document don't encode important genes, so they evolve very quickly because they have a higher tolerance of typo's and mutations.
So in an population pool that people use to assemble and come up with an consensus genome (keep in mind the population pool will have different gene variation), so it may turn out at a particular base pair position in the document, there is so much variation that the genome assembler can't conclusively come up with an consensus sequence or a reasonable distribution of base pair (A, T, C, G).
The problem is that bacteria are pretty fragile. So if you have a tardigrade that has some bacteria sitting on it (or the tardigrade just ate some), whatever process you use to extract the tardigrade DNA is also going to extract the bacterial DNA. Since this is done in solution, the bacterial and tardigrade DNA will be irrevocably mixed.
While they do wash and filter the tardigrades extensively and also starve them for several days before extracting their DNA, that's still not enough to completely remove all bacteria.