Acquisitions aren't success though. It's just "failing upwards" for the founders. Successful companies are self sustaining.
Acquisitions aren't success though. It's just "failing upwards" for the founders. Successful companies are self sustaining.
Companies are utterly un-important, they are simply vehicles.
Companies exist as an attempt to get all the money in the world, and most fail that goal. Apple is pretty close. Refusal to acknowledge failure as failure is pathological insanity. Getting paid to fail (or to "soft land" and save face on an outright failure) doesn't mean the fail didn't happen.
Well, that's what I said, companies are vehicles.
> It's difficult to retire on "product dividends.
But you can retire on corporate dividends. And when a companies shares are acquired you either get money or shares in the acquiring company.
> Companies exist as an attempt to get all the money in the world
How do you square that with 'it is hard to retire on product dividends'? Companies pay out dividends to their shareholders.
Companies clearly do not exist to 'get all the money in the world' because then the economy would grind to a halt.
> and most fail that goal.
All companies fail that goal. They fail every time they buy new resources, pay out salaries, rent offices, pay out dividends and so on.
In fact, the worst thing for a company is to have a whole pile of cash and nothing to do with it, that's money that is not currently working for the company in a meaningful way. That's why companies tend to manage their liquid reserves very carefully.
> Apple is pretty close.
Close to getting all the money in the world? No, not even remotely close. And even all that money that Apple has is indirectly owned by the shareholders of Apple. Either Apple will have to spend it or they will have to pay out. Having it sit there does them no good.
> Refusal to acknowledge failure as failure is pathological insanity.
Are you calling me insane in a roundabout way?
> Getting paid to fail (or to "soft land" and save face on an outright failure) doesn't mean the fail didn't happen.
Oh, that happens. But it's pretty rare. But better than chapter 11 if that's the alternative.
It takes one to know one.
But it's pretty rare.
Pretty rare? That's back to the beginning, because every acquisition means the bought company has explicitly failed to become "real" in a make-more-than-we-spend (and continually grow the "make more") sense.
But better than chapter 11 if that's the alternative.
I'd rather see 20-somethings lose everything and learn tough, introspective, life changing lessons, than see them running around with their "soft landing" $10 million paydays just because they had the right connections.
I think we're done here.
Either the founders/investors/employees succeed, or their product succeeds, but the company can never succeed absent of one/both of the above.
Maybe you care more about the company. You certainly shouldn't project your personal beliefs onto others. Many founders would love to see their pet idea continue without the tedium of running a company. Many founders and employees would be similarly happy to trade in the company letterhead for a bigger paycheck. It's only "selling out" if one was more in love with the idea of the company than with the idea of the product, and frankly I can see few reasons other than ego for that to be the case.
But it's a blatant, raw, undeniable failure when a company lets itself get acquired no matter how much money changes hands.
(this is one of the topics that induce harsh West Coast Cognitive Dissonance because it goes against what the billionaire priests of finance tell you to believe about your life)
You mean that when Intel acquired Altera that was a failure, and when Microsoft acquired Mojang that was a failure too? And Google with Android and so on. All 'blatant, raw, undeniable failures' according to you.
The 'end' is but a moment and it's very well possible to have a success even if it ends in one way or another. Success is a measure of the total net effect a company had. if the net effect was negative then a company can be classed a failure, if the net effect was positive then the company was a success.
Selling out is to sell a company with the specific intent to shut it down, that's different.
Let's take Mojang as an example. Mojang was run for many years by the same people. Maybe they simply got tired of it and wanted to move on to other things. Having a significant chunk of money in the bank is generally considered to be a good thing and from what I see minecraft is still working just fine. I find it hard to square that deal with the meaning of the word 'failure'. That's just trying to be too clever for my taste I prefer a simpler and more direct interpretation of words, this cleverness is really rather tiresome.
It looks as if the whole thing is constructed in such a way that it a negative association is attached to the success of others in a way that says more about the user of the words than about the people and events that it is supposed to describe.