Activist ejected from "public" meeting on secret copyright treaty for tweeting
boingboing.net
boingboing.net
Is there any historical precedent for worldwide corruption on this scale? Not to be overly dramatic, but this feels vaguely like the end of the free world.
Whose interests do you think those legislators are truly representing? Take a close look at the health care legislation process and try to find where either party's ideological goals are being represented in writing.
There's lip service being paid to helping the little guy and curtailing government, but in writing the entire discussion is laid bare as an argument over whose handouts go to whom.
And pardon me if I don't hold out hope for the Supreme Court to defend the public good from corporate interest. Their last few decisions in the general arena have been anything but reassuring.
Do I need to mention Kelo, Citizens, Exxon, Garcetti or a half-dozen other cases where public interests were given short-shrift in favor of corporate interests?
Do I need to post the entirety of the senate health care bill?
I have no trouble with Citizens or Garcetti v. Ceballos (how is that a "corporate interests" case???), but which Exxon case are you referring to (Google comes up with a lot of X v. Exxon cases)?
(I'd also note that I believe in the principle of the rule of law vs. the rule of man, but that would probably be pointless.)
The problem, of course, is that this treaty is being negotiated by many parties with competing interests, but no party is representing the people who will actually be affected by this treaty. The people discussing the treaty are paid for and bought by controlling copyright interests, and not by the people.
Therefore it is fundamentally different: it is not a negotiation at the behest of The People. It is a negotiation based on the trade and control powers of multinational corporations. It's diametrically opposed to freedom, because the free are not involved at any level in its construction, negotiation, and ratification. The fact that they are so secretive about the negotiations as to eject and ridicule third-party observes proves that they are not acting in the best interest of said third party observers.
(I would have no problems with the treaties being discussed / negotiated in secret, if there were bona fide representatives of People and specific safeguards against the treaty being unilaterally used to oppress the masses)
The representatives of the people in this process are the democratically elected Senators who must ratify the non-secret finished treaty.
Assuming the leaks are true, we do not need to speculate that it may be underhanded because it is being negotiated in secret. We can be as confident as we are in the veracity of the leaks that they are being underhanded because of the content of the treaty.
Secrecy is an irrelevant point. If this treaty was produced in an open and transparent manner I would still agree with warfangle that the treaty is unjust and in the US, unconstitutional.
Are you aware that details have been leaked? It sort of sounds like you may not be aware that while to some extent we are still speculating on the contents, it is well-founded speculation, not wild speculation.
You’ll note that I haven’t made any statement one way or the other regarding the treaty itself. You shouldn’t infer that I am for or against it based on what I’ve said. Yes, I do know the details have been leaked. You’re missing my point entirely, because the content of the treaty is completely irrelevant to what I’ve said. My point is simply that the fact that the treaty is being negotiated in secret has no bearing on the relative merits of the treaty itself. The secrecy is just an irrelevant procedural technicality of the negotiation process that’s being framed as some nefarious underhanded move that should invalidate the treaty. It’s being used as a scare tactic in place of debating the treaty itself. Argue for or against the treaty on its content, not how it was arrived at.
I’m perplexed at how it isn’t clear to people that the treaty is being negotiated in secret precisely to prevent just such a mob backlash as is occurring. And it’s not to prevent a backlash because there is some corporate/government conspiracy to control the masses at work. It’s because there are concrete procedural difficulties in negotiating something like this when the parties involved aren’t able to speak freely without having 6 billion rabid critics jump down their throats at every proposal.
Apparently it is.
Phone calls, letters, etc. are all just things for them to stew on. Ultimately, they can make whatever decision they want. Volunteer for political work and you'll see: letters will be tabulated and counted to favor one position or another, and at the end of the day it's just a number for the senator or representative to glance at for a few moments when considering what position to take, which in the end will almost definitely be the one handed down from their party.
The Gallery "staging areas" are located on the upper level of the Visitor Center near the Orientation Theater exits. Visitors are not allowed to bring battery-operated electronic devices (medical devices are permitted); cameras; creams, lotions or perfumes; strollers; or video recorders or any type of recording device into the Galleries. These items may be stored securely in the Gallery staging areas while visitors are in the Galleries.
What happened to those promised televised health care debates?
The rules of the US Government building aren't relevant. The meetings about the secrecy are being held in Mexico. They nearly required the attending public to sign NDAs and surrender electronics, but last minute deliberation removed those restrictions. Which suggests the ejection of a live-blogger appear quite unfounded.
The ACTA meetings themselves are being held at some other time, in an undisclosed location in Mexico.