I might be a bit slow on this one, but I don't see the problem with even a strictly enforced requirement for ride acceptance given that the driver's app is "on". Uber's business is in efficiently matching available drivers with riders, and adjusting the market price based upon the relative supplies. Drivers with the app "on" but not actually accepting rides messes with their price offering on both sides of the equation. At the margin, riders pay less in surge with an artificially inflated supply of rides, and the drivers on the other side receive less in surge pricing.
Is there something I'm missing here?