[1] Super Mario Bros. Special: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=txcEMPakkPg
[2] Golf: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XPSHI-1j1ZU
[3] Balloon Fight, Ice Climber, Excitebike: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eV-kZ_wPx-Y
It wasn't until hardware and insane innovation came together with Doom that consoles had a very real competitor in "action" video games. (perhaps Wolfenstein and its ilk could qualify, I remember it being big but never really registering as "mature" the way console games did)
This demo is, to me, extremely impressive because it's close to the NES version. But it also has all the hallmarks of PC attempts at platformers. It never "felt" right. The reasons are explained a bit here, but there were ultimately a lot of limitations that made it very hard to compete even graphically with commonly-available hardware.
Though by releasing Mario on the PC, might have cost Nintendo console marketshare. I do think people by Nintendo consoles often because of the games / game characters like Mario, Zelda, etc...
---
Best I can tell Jazz Jackrabbit did not sell 1MM copies, SMB3 sold 17MM. Doom ended up selling something like 3MM, but the key difference was it was an experience that didn't exist much on consoles, and Carmack & Co. did everything possible to make it futuristic compared to anything then possible on PC.
I just don't see an SMB copy doing anything noteworthy at that stage, and the end result probably would have stunk, too. But that was a limitation with the platform more than anything.
But mechanically, Jazz at best had parity and at worst would have been considered a low-tier platformer at best on the Super Nintendo.
I honestly don't know what it was with PC platformers of the era, if they were actually incapable of "feeling good" for some technical reason or if nobody ever, well, for lack of a nicer way of putting it, did it right. But they were always bizarrely floaty and had poor physics and feel. Whether or not the PC hardware could have competed on platformers, I do not ever recall playing one that felt as good as a console game did.
The Keen games were successful enough, and within a year (late 1991) had graphics and gameplay that were what I would consider SNES-like.
Being able to play Mario on a PC would've been a killer app for sure. The popularity of emulators since the mid-late 90s should be enough proof for that.
Obviously RTS and FPS turned out to be the defining genres of PC gaming because of the tight controls, netplay, and being able to take advantage of Moore's law, but I think Nintendo missed out on a good chance to expand their business.
And there's the problem. "Massively popular for PC games", at the time, would equate to "a serious flop for a first-party console game". People would buy an NES so their kids could play a popular game. Almost nobody who didn't already have one would buy a PC for similar reasons. And anyone who already had a PC almost certainly already had a console as well, so there'd be no meaningful additional market in PC ports. Nintendo had every reason in the world to make the decision they did, and none whatsoever to do otherwise.
> graphics and gameplay that were what I would consider SNES-like
You might, but no one else would. The Keen series's graphics are better than the NES could manage until very late into its lifecycle if at all, but they're certainly not up to what the SNES could do, even without the Mode 7 coprocessor.
So there's no reason why this couldn't have been the first item in that sequence of things.