I live near Oxford, UK, where we have the peerless Blackwells, an academic-biased but broad-based bookshop (http://bookshop.blackwell.co.uk/stores/oxford-bookshop/about...) where you can literally get lost for an afternoon. I would typically walk straight past Waterstones on the way there.
Now, since the Daunt era began, I spend almost as much time in Waterstones as I do in Blackwells. Waterstones is where I go if I want to be surprised with a new book I haven't yet heard of. The 'new titles' displays on the ground floor often showcase books from smaller publishers which I'd never have found myself. "Curated" is an overused word these days, but it's exactly what they're doing, and doing well.
What the article doesn't mention is that Waterstones, under previous ownership, took over other good UK bookshop chains - notably Ottakars and Dillons. This was generally met with rending of garments and gnashing of teeth, because Waterstones at the time was the lowest common denominator High Street bookshop. But Waterstones now is better than I remember Ottakars or Dillons ever being.