The Apple paradox -- how a fanatically secretive company fosters open innovation
xconomy.com
xconomy.com
There are different issues here, for example company culture as far as internal and external transparency, which is very low at Apple and very high at (say) Google. Then there's Jobs's intense control of product design, which I'm sure is only to the good. Then there's being controlling of users of developers through DRM and the app store (as the only distribution channel for iPhone apps) -- I'm not sure where they're going with that (hardware support for DRM? more closed development platforms?) and I'm not sure I like it.
What does he think Google should have based the OS on? Windows, where Microsoft won't let you change the interface? OSX which isn't available for non-Apple hardware? Symbian which has tons of problems? Palm OS (you'd have to buy them first)? Write an OS from scratch (which would take years + billions of dollars).
Android is based on Linux because it's the only sensible choice, the fact that Richard Stallman has some funny netbook this week has nothing to do with it.