Edit: Looks like I've hit a very sore point...
Edit: Looks like I've hit a very sore point...
Americans aren't killing Muslims in Iraq just because they are muslims. That's a straw-man.
> wherears Muslims killing Americans in the US are "terrorists"
(Some) Muslim extremists certainly are killing americans because of what they are and what they believe in. They are effectively called terrorists because they don't kill soldiers.
They go kill random civilians in the streets.
A soldier that would do the same would be charged with war-crime, and it happened.
Quit your post-modernist framework which is making you say despicable things frankly.
Then s/Muslims/Iraqis/. But then, what about Palestine, Syria, Lybia, ...? On the other hand, I'm sure they aren't killing Americans because they're Americans either... but because they the agressors.
> They go kill random civilians in the streets.
What would you do, if a technologically-superior country was killing your friends, family, children? They fight any way they can, and hurt us where it hurts us most.
> A soldier that would do the same would be charged with war-crime, and it happened.
Wait, more than 150k civilians were killed in Iraq. I don't recall seeing that many war-crime trials.
By who? The vast majority were killed by various insurgent and terrorist groups, and those groups are still killing thousands of people a year.
Such a great thing that we have such loose criteria on what it means to be a combatant.
Also FWIW I think my local news sources tend to write about it in about the same way they write about other forms of terrorism.
One other comment:
> A soldier that would do the same would be charged with war-crime, and it happened.
I'm sadly afraid this doesn't happens enough.
That said, there's a lot to say about the notions that "(American) soldiers are good, insurgents are evil"
We fought the nazis in every conceivable way, and although we were "terrorists" and they were proper soldiers we still think of ourselves as the good guys.
That's a convenient excuse. The number of civilian causalties in Iraq makes me unlikely to believe it.
I only pointed out that soldier is very well defined.
(And if they shoot at random civilian they should be bought to court and sentenced, although I suspect we see that far to rarely)
> Edit: Looks like I've hit a very sore point...
What you said is wrong because you use wrong words. Try changing soldier to hero and we almost agree although I would still hold that attacking random civilians is bad anyway.
Intentionally, that's the point! It's absurd that some words are "right" and some are "wrong", when they essentially mean the same thing - a murderer killing others, for some definition of others.
That said :
> essentially mean the same thing - a murderer killing others, for some definition of others.
There is a again a massive difference between a good cop ending a life to save others and a brutal robber ending a life to bet away after a robbery.
As for the soldiers that invaded Iraq I'd say you should judge the politicians first.
I guess a lot of the soldiers felt a lot like the German soldiers that invaded certain European countries and were surprised to be shot at when they were told and many honestly thought they came to protect the locals against an imminent attack from British forces.
Edit: and lets not forget that it was lame European pacifist politicians that let Hitler get so far.
I'm not sure what gives certain Americans such a knack for injecting Anti-European sentiment. Is this what they're taught in history classes, or something else?
I have had a huge interest in wartime history when I was younger though which might explain a bit.
Actually Hitler was much beloved in the United States, right until quite close to the start of the war. Seen as a champion against communism -- like other murderers were later, e.g. Pinochet.
I can rationalize why somebody struggling in the great depression would look up to the apparent prosperity that Hitler seemed to be bringing to Germany prior to the war.
I don't care about stupid points, and these are not mine either but why downvote for no apparent reason?
You say "that's the theme of public discourse" as if this is something novel. On the contrary, I think any nation attacked on it's own ground is likely to view the perpetrator as a terrorist; in my opinion this is consistent with the US usage. For instance, victims of a US drone attack might view the US as terrorists in that scenario.