How online security cards fails (or how security economics trumps engineering)
lightbluetouchpaper.org
lightbluetouchpaper.org
My major objection to OpenID is that it takes a single-site registration/login experience, with one consistent look and feel, and throws two extra HTTP requests and a completely different look and feel into the mix. To me that makes the experience more confusing and inconvenient, not less.
For the masses, the browser bounce is a big problem, as we're relying on the user to recognise a genuine login page (as you noted). I'd prefer to configure the browser with my OpenID and let that deal with the request.