In Arbitration, a ‘Privatization of the Justice System’
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
Arbitration is really only fair and effective between equal peers that can choose to split the costs of the arbitration, and agree upon an arbitrator together.
In cases of arbitration between a large entity and a single small customer, the large entity wins virtually every single time. The top 10 arbitration firms in the USA only rule in the favor of the consumer/employee 1.6% of the time [1]
There's not a single health plan available in many states that does not require agreeing to binding arbitration for coverage. None of them allow you to opt out, even if you're willing to pay more. Sign away your right to sue, or no coverage for you. Consider that under health care reform, one is required to purchase one of these plans. There are dozens of industries that are like this, where it is virtually impossible to receive a service or a good of that class without agreeing to mandatory binding arbitration, such as residential ISPs.
Add into the fact there is almost no way to appeal decisions, make no mistake, Companies are not doing this for your benefit.
The term "kangaroo court" comes to mind.
[1]http://consumerist.com/2007/07/26/support-the-arbitration-fa...
This is the worst part. There's really no choice for 'the little guy' on whether or not to sign these things. But this article and others demonstrate it to be an unfair system people should be able to keep out of (that's what those rights are for!) So how do we solve it?
It seems like legally requiring the option of going to court should work. When there is no other option but to waive your rights, the rights may as well not exist.
When everything is privatized under libertarian philosophy, what basic rights do you have left other than the power of money?
So in essence, the government is supporting rule by private actors. Glib, but relevant: http://brianmay.com/brian/brianssb/pix/14/NHS_who_gets_all_t...
And are you just entirely ignoring that the company effectively holds all the cards in this poker game? What power does the individual have?