I've spent more than half a decade in each, vim has better navigation (being able to do something like `2bcw' or :1,$s/foo/bar/ or even just straight up hjkl makes quick edits far superior - one could say it's a better editor, because it is. hell, it was based on 'ed'). Emacs is the better integrated-development environment (ecosystem and able to customize to you hearts content.. eventually you'll run into a VIMscript wall and want to shoot yourself), especially now that emacs24,25 + ELPA + Marmalade make it about 20 minutes to go from a fresh install of any OS to 'productive'.
VIMs worth learning just so you see the other side of the fence, but if your goal is just productivity, CLion does everything that that VIM configuration does and more (and there are GNU/Emacs key-bindings).