But for me you missed the biggest point - credit cards. Some London black taxis take cards, some pretend their machines are broken, others don't take the cards in the first place which they will proudly tell you with a big user-unfriendly notice in their windows.
The second two ruin it for all the black taxis, as I can't flag any taxi down unless I have actual physical money, which I hardly ever have, because I don't know which of the three it will be.
Issues like price, time to pick up, knowledge of the area, even wanting to support local businesses etc are irrelevant if I can't pay them.
I've used this in Paris and Munich in the last year.
> I've used this in Paris and Munich in the last year.
Did you manage in Munich without cash at all? My expectation would have been that you needed cash regardless to pay for (most) small things (coffee, bakeries etc. etc.). Credit or even debit card use is not very widespread, essentially the only time I use mine is at ATMs and to pay online for services that don’t support direct debit.
If the taxis in your city don't take credit cards, or you can't book online, or there is no competition, then just petition your local authority to fix it before Uber comes along and "fixes" it.