No, it's an argument against using statistics without first considering the strength of your data.
This is exactly what weirds people out about LessWrong folk. They talk about a tool as if it's a religion.
The people need to get over it. LW crowd is a group of people studying a pretty specific set of subjects, focused around a single website. It's typical for such a group to develop their own jargon and insider jokes, which may look weird from outside. It's normal.
I'll speculate you have some sort of meta-heuristic and only apply this catch-22 under those circumstances? E.g. this catch-22 only applies to weird and socially disapproved topics?