> Working with Alak Ray (Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai), Di Stefano points out that we have found low-metallicity stars known to have planets elsewhere in the galaxy. And while we can couple the occurrence of Jupiter-class planets with stars that have higher metallicity, there seems to be no such correlation when we’re dealing with smaller, rocky worlds like the Earth. Perhaps, then, we shouldn’t dismiss planets in globular clusters.
If you compare that to low-metallicity stars in the galaxy proper, there are reasons why those might have planets that are not easily afforded to star systems located in globular clusters. Our galaxy is rich in dust and gas clouds that are also inhomogeneous. For example, a metal-poor star may be born out of a low-metal gas cloud and then attract a metal-rich dust disc later. These things are expected to happen a lot less often in globular clusters.
Our sun is not a particularly early third generation star. Given that it would take a civilization about a billion years to spread through the galaxy to all liveable planets ... some civilization should have done that up to 4-5 billion years ago.
If life can happen in 2nd generation stars as well, it should have happened 6-8 billion years ago.
Obviously this hasn't happened.
I only see 3 reasonable explanations:
1) Drake equation is too optimistic. By a huge factor (2-300 million times too optimistic)
2) It's not a problem, because civilizations kill themselves before doing interstellar travel and while we are on the way to doing that but not quite there yet.
3) There's something we don't know
But yeah "We are first, we are rare or we are screwed..." Pretty much sums it up if there are "great filters" to life we really don't understand them yet.
The biggest problem with the Drake equation is that we are using a sample of one, it also doesn't take into account great filters that will prevent the development of intelligent life, technological civilizations and interstellar ones. Our technology jumped from sticks and stones to interplanetary rockets in 10,000 or so years after sticking to those sticks and stones for about 200,000 - 250,000 years. We still have had people living in the Stone Age during ww2 and some still do today. We probably know less about how a civilization might develop into a technological one than we know about how life can evolve.
Cargo cults existed because that's how humans work, that's how humans learn. That's how the machinery that is our brain operates. We copy behavior. We do not discover, learn, think rationally, or any of that (though some of those are tricks we've learned at some point and now make sure to teach our children, but they're learned behaviors, very different from human brains, similar to how you can run logic circuits or multiplications on neural networks).
Here's a stupid assumption that page makes as well. It assumes that cargo cultism had no chance of success. That's just stupid. They built these planes. It would only take someone pushing them off a cliff and paying attention to their fall to discover lift. I don't mean explaining and calculating lift (we can't even do that (the problem "here's a wing shape, now calculate the lift equations" is still unsolved except for special cases, doubly so in supersonic situations, so their chances seem limited). Once they see lift they would only need to get propellers rotating, already a much, much simpler problem. It would certainly not be impossible to make a 10-15 minute human powered flight, or they could simply learn to ride the winds. Difficult, but given enough tries that would certainly work.
Therefore I'd like to offer a very much different explanation for cargo cultism : it's how humans learn. Had these tribes had 100 years or so to figure it out, we would have seen one land in a homemade bamboo airplane on Haiti.
Engine powered flight is much easier and done a century earlier. Yet it still required steel working and internal combustion engine technologies. Small Pacific islands are just not likely to provide access to the necessary iron ore and oil deposits.
But I don't fault them for trying.
Aviation is like Greek science : for a millenium it was stuck in a local optimum. They had seen a working wing design (bird wings) and imitated them, and kept imitating them, failure after failure after failure after failure after failure after failure, for close to a thousand years, or ore if you believe that Daedalus and/or Archytas actually tried it. And while Daedalus sounds a bit incredible, Archytas is just barely on the side of what is achievable. It took someone touring Europe demonstrating a circus trick (lifting a man) with a kite imported from China to make them realize their mistake, or at least make them try something even slightly different. Then, having seen the kites lift people, people tried other wing designs it suddenly took off : less than 50 years until we had stable gliders (God help whoever tries to use a kite for flying, something I learned as a 7 year old. Umbrellas work better, at least stability wise, until they break), another 70 years until we had stable powered flight. Another 15 years and we had commercial airlines and weaponized airplanes.
You are assuming an advanced civilization that spread through the universe would either announce itself or we'd be able to detect it.
The scenario that nobody mentions is that they're already here.
They might not be useful today, but you've got to start somewhere.
As I said: It's certainly a good thing to think about these things, but... :)
EDIT: Assuming it generally agrees with observed facts, a good sign for any scientific theory is how much it constrains the explanation/solution space. (Paraphrased, obviously. For the life of me I cannot remember who said this. Perhaps David Deutsch?) I don't think the Drake Equation adequately constrains the solution/explanation space.
We have come to know the number of stars around pretty well - at least in our galaxy. Thanks to Kepler and other exoplanet hunters, we know know alot more about the number of planets. These findings are used to constrain the Drake equation.
The rest of the parameters we don't know much about, yet.
I would hold judgement till we explore Europa. Depending on what we find there life may or may not be common in the universe.