Or, at least, they coerce the fast pace internet viewer into having that first impression. I know its silly, but the average viewers mind will subconsciously attribute more effort and quality - thus, credibility - to a polished photo than to any gradient.
It sadly does not make a difference if its merely a stock photo bought for a few bucks. It still works.
Also, a photo gives a more "real", less abstract impression, so the target customer can relate. You can't relate to a gradient. So the photo should be chosen according to the target customer.
I agree though that some effort should also be put into technical aspects, e.g. making the photo file size as small as possible.