Hacker News Reader

Comment by japaw | Hacker News Reader

No they probably do not have the users Facebook password, but they do not need it for scraping, because they can just use their own use for that.

I have looked around on Facebook and it looks like one can see other users friend list, even if you are not in their immediate network.

Even if Facebook has a limitation, like you can only see the friend list of friends of friends the company behind this app could probably make some fake Facebook users and befriends someone on each university to get an ok coverage.

View on HN

It depends on the privacy settings. Though the several iterations of privacy scaremongering and Facebook changing defaults resulted in people locking up their accounts like crazy, friend lists seem to still be visible semi-publicly for quite a lot of people. With more news like that, this will probably change too, though.

> Though the several iterations of privacy scaremongering

I'd argue that this is another case which shows that the privacy scaremongering isn't scaremongering, but the privacy issues are real.

Though those concerns may be real, the privacy issue being discussed is still a trick employed by Facebook. By redirecting people's fear towards the amount of information that the public can see, they were able to keep them from talking about the original issue -- what Facebook tracks, saves, and uses for advertising.

It's totally a POV issue IMO, that's why I phrased it that way :).

For me, half of the Facebook's utility was the ability to check people out without having to commit to a relation with them first. A publishing platform, a little bit like personal pages of old, but much more streamlined and accessible to the mainstream. But it turned out there's enough bad actors around (stalkers, marketers) that people voted against this, and so Facebook is now a very locked down place. I think most of those fears people have are overblown, but well, that's only my opinion and it seems that most people disagree.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com