You don't know what this means. Monads are precisely about composition.
You don't know what this means. Monads are precisely about composition.
It's true that in a certain sense monads are "about composition", but that doesn't mean they aren't without issues, and I certainly think it's appropriate to call monads non-declarative. In fact, I think "being in a monad" is more or less the essence of what it is to be imperative - which is why they're useful! Quite often we want to be imperative.
The word "compositional" is quite vague. I wish people would stop tossing it around so lightly without explaining what they meant by it.
For example, monads don't "compose" as nicely as applicatives. You can automatically compose two applicatives and have a guarantee the the result obeys the applicative laws. Like you say, for monads you would have to write your own monad transformer, and hopefully verify it is still a law abiding monad. You don't have to write a transformer for applicatives.