> otherwise you're effectively mining a very expensive altcoin which no merchants or exchanges accept.
This is not the case. You could run XT for example and remain compatible, which was precisely its adoption strategy? It just simply did not reach consensus (aka CPU power).
> By mining with Bitcoin XT you will produce blocks with a new version number. This indicates to the rest of the network that you support larger blocks. When 75% of the blocks are new-version blocks, a decision has been reached to start building larger blocks that will be rejected by Bitcoin Core nodes.
(from https://bitcoinxt.software/)