Bradley Kuhn: I Think I Just Got Patented
ebb.org
ebb.org
Waiting until you are personally inconvenienced is the patent equivalent of going through the sequence that ends on 'and when they came for me there was nobody left to stand up for me'.
Software patents are bad, period.
The very few cases where there was merit to a software patent are outweighed massively by the downsides.
http://www.ipwatchdog.com/inventing/prior-art/
Still, this puts the burden of proof on the person claiming prior art. I'd like to see a reform of patent law that would make the infringing patent holder responsible for the legal fees for proving the prior art, if it's valid.
That would:
1. Force the potential infringer to do a more rigorous search prior to filing the patent.
2. Gives the person with prior art a little more leverage in negotiations.
Am I misguided?
Any book will serve as published prior art against a patent on page numbering. It does not have to be the main subject.
It is all well and good until some moron (genius?) comes along and patents these simple ideas.
Bob hasn't released this software to the world yet, because he's working on other parts of a larger system.
In this scenario, should Bob consider filing a patent in order to protect his invention (assuming it would get discovered eventually), or is there some way for him to file a record of what his method does so that he doesn't have to worry about someone coming to patent what he's doing out from under him?
(I'm not at all versed in patent law, so I apologize if the answers to this are obvious)
I get why people call software patents evil, but they seem kind of necessary to protect against bigger companies (at least until the patent system is 'fixed').
The problem is litigating the twenty or so patents any large company can pull out of the bag, which, if you squint at the blurry lines, might overlap with what you are working on.
Basically, yes, having a patent yourself would be a great help, but it doesn't solve the problem when people are getting patents on what amounts to standard practice.
http://inventors.about.com/od/provisionalpatent/a/Provisiona...