The Man Who Would Tame Cancer
nautil.us
nautil.us
E.g. a universal cancer vaccine based on this approach: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4471666/
E.g. disable part of the mechanism by which telomerase lengthens telomeres: http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2015-05/cndi-csa05111...
People such as the SENS folk have been advocating this approach for more than a decade, but the research community is slow in adopting it. The vast majority of cancer research continues to be a matter of doing very expensive things that only work for one tiny subtype of cancer. If we're doing expensive things, then they should be efficient expensive things.
Do you have a source for this? Has someone actually measured telomere elongation in a bunch of different tumor biopsies and reported detection in >90%?
Ah I see the article mentions this. But years ago it was understood that cancerous cells originally happened because of damage from short teleomeres? That end-of-life cells would divide badly and malfunction, sometimes by reproducing endlessly.
So its a matter of timing? Young people want to keep their teleomeres long; but if you get cancerous cells then you want to clip them all. Sadly, that means end-of-life for the rest of your body. But no more cancer.
"Telomeres are critical for maintaining genomic integrity and studies show that telomere dysfunction or shortening is commonly acquired during the process of tumor development. Short telomeres can lead to genomic instability, chromosome loss and the formation of non-reciprocal translocations; and telomeres in tumor cells and their precursor lesions are significantly shorter than surrounding normal tissue."[0]
"Cancer cells require a mechanism to maintain their telomeric DNA in order to continue dividing indefinitely (immortalization). A mechanism for telomere elongation or maintenance is one of the key steps in cellular immortalization and can be used as a diagnostic marker in the clinic. Telomerase, the enzyme complex responsible for elongating telomeres through the addition of telomere repeats to the ends of chromosomes, is activated in approximately 80% of tumors."[0]
It's not as simple as long vs short.
Aschacher; Wolf; Enzmann; Kienzl (2015). "ALINE-1 induces hTERT and ensures telomere maintenance in tumour cell lines". Oncogene. doi:10.1038/onc.2015.65.
Aschacher et al write: "In about 80% of tumour cells, telomere maintenance is controlled by telomerase (TA), a reverse transcriptase, which adds DNA repeats onto chromosomal ends."12, 22, 23, 24, 25
I checked all five references and none had anything about this 80% of tumors number. It appears to be made up.
http://hmg.oxfordjournals.org/content/10/7/677.full
"Telomerase activity has been found in almost all human tumors but not in adjacent normal cells."
Also, Shay and Bacchetti write: "With very few exceptions, tumor cells were assayed by the PCR-based TRAP protocol... negative samples from the few studies that used the less sensitive assay without PCR amplification of telomerase products, have been disregarded".
These papers are pretty old, so I thought it would be interesting to find out what has been learned about the TRAP protocol in the time since. Today, we know those methods lead to false positives:
"The original TRAP method has several drawbacks. Initially, the CX oligonucleotide, which complementarily overlaps with TS for several bp, is used in the amplification of PCR products. It results in the dimerization of primers and products that emerge due to the interaction between primers. Even when using the optimal ACX primer with the noncomplementary TS end, a background signal may emerge during the analysis of concentrated extracts from tumor tissues [14]. An additional problem is encountered when using reverse primers which completely correspond to telomeric repeats. The primers are not annealed at the matrix edges during PCR (as a result of periodicity in telomeres), and hence false signals emerge." http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3347595/
It would be interesting to see more recent data on this.
Is there similar data available regarding telomeres?
>"Critics have dismissed the cancer-study endeavour as time-consuming, out-of-touch with the realities of basic science and unlikely to produce interpretable results. “It’s a naÏveté that by simply embracing this ethic, which sounds eminently reasonable, that one can clean out the Augean stables of science,” says Robert Weinberg, a cancer biologist at the Whitehead Institute for Biomedical Research in Cambridge, Massachusetts." http://www.nature.com/news/cancer-reproducibility-project-sc...
Probably due to all the retractions he had to deal with out of his lab recently: http://retractionwatch.com/2015/07/06/cancer-research-retrac...
I wonder how much he still believes what he wrote in 2000.
I'm curious how this elementary error crept in here (he means mRNA, not rRNA, and rDNA is not a thing). Poor editing? A gap in the education of the good doctor?
Please -- it's regimen, not regiment. One is a course of medical treatment, the other is a military unit.
I'm beginning to see this coinage more often, alongside the ever-popular reign where the writer means rein, as in reign (what a monarch does to a kingdom) instead of rein (what a cowboy does to a horse).
What happened to editing? While we're on the subject, what happened to literacy? I expect to walk into a bookstore and see a poster: "Buy 'The Tragedy of Illiteracy', now available as an audiobook."