Note that DenisM uses food as his example and try to find his meaning instead of the few exceptions.
yes, that's the starting point of my argument, thank you for phrasing it clearly. The next step is that future demand for durable goods is not a good savings mechanism for a number of reasons:
1. The demand isn't large enough for a whole generation of people
2. Those goods have to be stored and maintained, which is
costly and eats into the savings
3. It may unpredictably lose value due to technological
innovation, and if you made a poor bet you will starve
when that happens
Therefore the premise of my argument is that the idea of long-term savings is fictitious.Absent that there are only so many way to defuse the demographic bomb:
1. Saddle the young with debt by enticing them to spend beyond their means. Later they are compelled to pay via social norms and coercion of the state.
2. Collude on ownership of a crucial scarce resource such as land or oxygen. Collusion is likely to kill the economy very quickly though.
3. Make more babies. Costly in the short term, especially given that anyone who is making babies is also under the opression of debt, and the more babies the more crushing that debt is.
Although I should also mention "The Last Fool" concept. Those long-term savings won't be fictitious if you aren't the last fool left with them, i.e. you find another "fool" to sell them too.
But as you note that's a very iffy thing, certainly not something you should bank on, so to speak.
(Hmmm, you left out the Soilent Green option ... it's already being discussed by "serious thinkers". And there are less unpleasant ways to abrogate explicit and implicit promises to older generations.)
Alternative to debt burden would be oppressive taxes, but this has bad side-effects as well:
1. Taxes are not as discriminating against the young as situation dictates (debt is very discriminative)
2. People actually feel angry when money is taken from them via taxes. They are a lot less angry when they willfully spend themselves into debt. They even feel guilty when they can't pay. Bottom line is that it's easier to enforce because voluntary compliance is so much higher and political resistance to "pay your debt" is harder to imagine than to "pay high taxes".
3. Taxes depress economic development, while debt increases it (at the expense of the boom-bust volatility).
So I don't really see any realistic alternatives to the debt burden.
There is a very remote hope that technology brings us basic necessities too cheap to meter so that we don't have save for retirement. But that's really out there.
I wouldn't assume our current political order survives this looming mess (heck, many including me argue it didn't survive the Civil War or FDR).
This is what the Australian government decided to do. $4000 per child, no questions asked. (subsequent governments have fiddled with this and pandered to their support base, but the concept still remains)
The treasurer came out with a phrase 'one for mum, one for dad, one for the country'.
It worked. Birth rates are now higher than they have ever been.
I'm normally against this type of government wastage. But it's not hard to see that the $4000 will be earnt back within a ~25 year period once the child becomes an adult and starts paying taxes, even when you take inflation and future value of the $4000 into account. The $4000 was being paid out of revenue at the time as the government had no debt. (subsequent governments have started to borrow again, being unable to be fiscally responsible more than a couple of years)
It's actually the smartest strategy of your three, because the old people need to have as many young taxpayers working as possible.
In the 50's, the marginal top income US tax rate was 90%, but the exemptions for dependents were very substantial.
However they weren't indexed for inflation so they became relatively trivial over time before Reagan got the Congress to index them. Perhaps a return to that tax policy is worth a try?
I'm living in a building that was built in the 1920's. It is definitely still useful.
True, consumer goods generally don't last that long, but capital goods can last for a half-century or more.
Even then only if population continues to rise - if population drops as it does in almost all developed countries your land will be worth a lot less. Imagine a world where there are 1000 old people who can't work but own land, and then there are 100 young who can work and need a place to live. The first 100 buildings will sell/rent for some amount of food, the remaining 900 old people will die of starvation because there is nothing they can offer to the young in exchange for food.
Of course, that mechanism is in trouble the minute the market starts to contract or collapse.
Not: cash speculative stocks bubble inflated real estate suitable for a shrinking demographic managed investments consumer junk