Hacker News Reader

I upvoted you, but I want to add text in agreement since such upvotes can't be seen as an endorsement. gavman's warning about the reputation of the venue is unwarranted.

View on HN

I talked to my apartment mate about it. He said that when he showed the article to his advisor, she had the reaction of "they're pay to publish". I can't speak to the reputability of the journal, just providing his response.

EDIT: sounds like a misunderstanding more than anything.

Here's [0] a link to the rankings of nature journals. Nature Communications is 3rd in general science, and Nature is 1st.

Tim Gowers and the freedom of knowledge group are pushing hard on journal fees.

[0]http://www.nature.com/npg_/company_info/impact_factors.html

Old post :

I can speak to the reputability of your friend's program. The statement is jaw dropping. It is so wrong as to make it hard for me to believe he goes to an accredited university.

As I said in a comment below, he's at a top tier program (CMU), so it's likely I didn't understand his adverse reaction. You mention below his/his advisor's adverse reaction may be about "a movement to move to no cost journals", not about reputation. When I see him tonight I'll ask.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com