why Java instead of... well, i guess there isn't a language w/ GC and an ecosystem as "mature" as Java.
with clojure, which is indeed shiny and new, some people have cake and eat it too: speed of the jvm + flexibility of scripting. i guess a samish sort of thing could be accomplished w/ jython+Java if clj is too flashy.
anywho, i hear the "don't go for the glamor," thing and indeed try (i.e. make a conscious effort) to lag 'teh new hotness' by some interval. ES5 strict is usually good enough. indeed, tail calls are the one coolest feat.s ES6 to me, and they're pretty much everywhere unimplemented, including Babel, except maybe for some special cases.
w/ Java... it's a language i wish would move toward vanishing -- or at least go one layer deeper than everyday application development. when i first started writing applets, it was the coolest thing ever: Sun was awesome, the same program ran everywhere, there was automagic memory management, etc... now, Oracle's laying down all kinds of noise a/b owning the language, there are other runs-everywhere platforms/methods (ES, LLVM), and the Java language itself just looks incredibly noisy unless one uses some of the really excellent (but wo/man-hour costly) tooling expressly designed for handling it.