Makes sense for Twitter to do this, with a couple conditions:
1. Keep existing users happy by letting them opt-in but not forcing them to, and letting them easily switch back
2. Default new users to the algorithmic timeline to get them hooked by providing good content right away (note: from people they aren't following?).
As an existing Twitter user with a highly curated timeline that I'm very happy with, I have no problem with this at all unless they force me to start using it.