Will Apple only allow apps to run ads served by them in the future?
jasonlbaptiste.com
jasonlbaptiste.com
They aren't banning location-based ads, they are banning the use of the Core Location framework when it is being used only for advertising.
They are protecting a good user experience. For privacy reasons, applications that use Core Location need to ask for permission to do so. They don't want a bunch of ad-based apps asking the user for permission when they don't really need to know any location info. It's that simple.
If you know the user's location anyway, you can show location-based ads.
I'm not saying that Apple isn't going to try to take over the ad market for their devices, but all the recent speculation based on the news of the ban is just short-sighted.
hacker news, i cry for you.
"Developers will love it too, as it will serve as a semi loss leader, the same way the iTunes store does"
Wait, the iTunes store that rakes 30% of app transactions? That's a loss leader? It's a break-even leader in music, but is probably enormously profitable in apps.
"Payouts and rates that put AdMob to shame." Having one ad network compete for developers, rather than dozens (all of which compete on one point: how much developers make off of them) will lead to higher CPMs? Please repeat high school economics.
That they "love to control everything" is not convincing. It seems to me that they are usually motivated by an unwillingness to depend on third-parties for things central to their business, not that they intend to actively disrupt anybody else's business just for the sake of control. What beef does Apple have with Fusion Ads or The Deck, and application developers that currently use them?
In truth, I'm not even convinced that they intend to open up that ad network for third-party developers, and not simply use it for themselves. Consider U.S. patent application #20090265214:
Among other disclosures, an operating system presents one or more advertisements to a user and disables one or more functions while the advertisement is being presented. At the end of the advertisement, the operating system again enables the function(s). The advertisement can be visual or audible. The presentation of the advertisement(s) can be made as part of an approach where the user obtains a good or service, such as the operating system, for free or at reduced cost.
Ordinarily I'd dismiss this as merely speculative and not likely to see the light of day, but this lists Steve Jobs listed among the inventors.
I suspect Apple will release an Advertising SDK that relies on Quattro, take 30% of the profits - less than most advertising networks take - and cut developers a single check, which will be mighty convenient. However, Apple's not likely to enforce that developers use only their advertising SDK. Many iPhone application developers that use advertising know that using multiple ad sources and doing some simple yield optimization performs better than a single ad source - even the most privileged ad network doesn't perform as well as multiple ad networks used in conjunction. Banning an AdMob or a Millenial or a Google AdSense would result in significant backlash.
I believe zefhous is completely right - this is about protecting the user experience, nothing more.
I have to wonder what the value of ads on a mobile phone is anyway, especially on a phone without multitasking. I imagine the click-through rates are very low, and that conversion rates are zero. The only value that could possibly arise is increased brand-recognition of the advertiser.
(My experience with ads on Android is that they are usually annoying enough for me to insta-uninsall the app. They provide no value, but they do ensure that I stop using your app and consider someone else's paid version.)