Tim Berners-Lee: https everywhere considered harmful
w3.org
w3.org
Who are you and what did you do with the inventor of the WWW? Redirects are an easy solution to deprecated http links. And I still wish you understood DRM. http://www.theguardian.com/technology/blog/2013/mar/12/tim-b...
Instead of ranting, downplaying the EFF and others for improving the situation or wishing for the impossible, TBL missed the opportunity to support adoption of http/2, which might not be perfect (PHK mentioned rushed process and protocol complexity) but it has been touted to supersede http/1, https and spdy.
btw: there's also unauthenticated opportunistic encryption like tcpcrypt which works via server and client plugins.
It's not that encryption is bad, it's that the https method encourages lazy thinking.
Call me pessimist, but I think that any method which relies on "user education" is doomed from the start. Any UX designer can tell you that users do not read error messages and just click by them ASAP to get back to what they were doing before the computer so rudely interrupted them.
The problem is of course that moving things from http: space into
https space, whether or not you keep the rest of the URI the same,
breaks any links to. Put simply, the HTTPS Everywhere campaign
taken at face value completely breaks the web.
Of course, in reality, anyone who moves to HSTS also adds a rewrite rule that redirects incoming http vistors to the https URI. In fact, Let's Encrypt even does it automatically: https://github.com/letsencrypt/letsencrypt/blob/master/letse...His complaint is completely spurious.