Do you make any attempt to interview for things are inherently subjective?
At least for some positions, personality and culture fit might be important.
At least for some positions, personality and culture fit might be important.
In that case - if we would decide in favor of A - I guess I would skip that reason.
But if you design the testing sufficiently broad - then you not just get a very good insights of where an applicant's strength lie but also enough "reasons" to give for negative decision - which also are helpful for the applicant to improve.