This is an odd criticism. Why is this any different from letting Google store my spreadsheets or Mint.com store all my banking/cc or 37Signals store all my business contacts. Is it because it's a startup? So much for cloud computing...
I think cashier live would have a chance if it polished up its code, released it under GPL, partnered with accounting firms instead of directly CC processing firms, and went into the premium fee support / consulting business while learning to franchise sales to put qualified reps on the floor of customer's shops to hook things up.
This will turn them into every other POS vendor. I don't see what GPL'ing the code will do (that's not a feature to most people). Same with accounting firms... I'm going to ask my accounting firm for advice on a POS system??? For most small businesses, your accountant is guy that works out his house and can barely use e-mail.