> It is not permitted for closed source kernel blobs; those are violations too.
They are not permitted by the license; for them to be violations, they would have to be derivative works that require a license.
If you have a reference to copyright case law in any jurisdiction holding that to be the case, that would be interesting.
I think its clear that certain parties (including the FSF) would like this to be perceived to be a violation; it also seems fairly clear that this type of act has been a fairly established practice around Linux, but that those with that view have not take action to vindicate it in court, perhaps because while they'd like it to be perceived to be the case, they have little confidence that courts would agree with them, and the one thing they'd like less than active disagreement with some people engaging in the practice that they don't like is a black-and-white ruling vindicating the ongoing practice and rejecting the FSF view on the legal requirements.