Police want to destroy iPad because they cannot delete illegal image
reddit.com
reddit.com
This is the country where you can be prosecuted for possessing porn featuring a 'tiger' which is actually a man in a tiger suit. [0]
This is also the country where you can be prosecuted for possessing porn that is sent to you unsolicited via Whatsapp. [1]
This is also the country where you can be convicted for tweeting a bad joke, lose your job in the process, and have to go to one of the highest courts in the land to get it overturned [2]
The 2008 'extreme porn' law is one of a host of extremely fucking terrifying laws that allow the authorities to essentially destroy your life on a whim (see also: Communications Act 2003, Racial and Religious Hatred Act 2006). It doesn't matter if the evidence isn't credible, they can drag you through the courts and ruin your reputation without ever getting a conviction.
Combine this with one of the most effective mass surveillance programs in the world, you realise we have already built a ready-made turnkey authoritarian dictatorship.
The really scary part is that nobody seems to give a shit.
[0] https://www.vice.com/en_uk/read/andrew-holland-tiger-porn-88...
[1] http://m.computing.co.uk/ctg/news/2358930/backbytes-someone-...
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2008/4/part/5/crossheadi...
It's somewhat disturbing how broad the definition is. For example if an image is in itself not considered pornographic, but is used in a loosely defined pornographic context it can be considered extreme pornography.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law#United_King... [1] http://www.gazettelive.co.uk/news/teesside-news/anime-fan-co...
I'm disgusted.
British people tend to take on a superior tone when American politics is discussed. We love to mock the obsessions with guns and single-issue politics. At least freedom of speech actually means something there, is protected by the constitution and valued by normal people. We have absolutely no right to act superior.
If this is the case, then simple "I have uploaded illegal files to one unspecified account" should get the whole datacentre destroyed :)
At this point if you like s&m you might end up going to jail for "rape" porn.
That said, it's a reddit comment without much info. Even taking it at face value my guess is that there's no official procedure or interest in bothering by the police but they can easily scrap the thing without any fuss (or mark as destroyed, wipe, and "repurpose" if you're feeling cynical.)
Creating or possessing such a picture is a separate offence, but (stupidly if I may say so) still an offence.
As always talk to a lawyer, HN is the wrong place to ask legal advice.
My point was that nobody is "going to HN for legal advice." Someone who is not the OP, who likely will never see the comment I replied to, posted the thread on Reddit. That's what I was pointing out to you.