Did they think perhaps there would be public outcry the other direction meaning Apple would look like it was harboring terrorist information if they didn't comply to a public request?
Did they think perhaps there would be public outcry the other direction meaning Apple would look like it was harboring terrorist information if they didn't comply to a public request?
This is exactly what is happening. It's a political hail mary to get the easiest-to-see use case of forcing privacy violations on american corporations and users legally protected in court precedent. Of course, under this interpretation, there's the disturbing implication they had to wait this long (after the revelation about PRISM) to find a case that so well matched their political agenda.
It's also a little worrying that they are going public, because normally that's not necessary for court verdicts. Perhaps they're preparing for legislative action if the case fails?
Pro-Privacy: Cruz (R), Paul (R), Sanders (D)
Pro-Surveillance: Trump (R), Rubio (R), Bush (R)
Moderate: Carson (R), Clinton (D)
[0] https://nakedsecurity.sophos.com/2016/02/02/where-do-us-pres...
Also, I would put Clinton in the rabidly anti-privacy camp if just for this stance she took after San Bernadino: http://www.nbcnews.com/tech/security/could-hillary-clinton-s.... She clearly has no desire for privacy from governments except through legal constraints. Furthermore, her understanding of technology as demonstrated by stances on her email servers, on encryption, and on video games, is outweighed by her desire to either (ab)use technology regardless, or attempt to intervene in it. Not great for an executive, which you would hope would be conservative (slow to move) OR knowledgeable OR defer to a strong cabinet.
Off topic, but I am going to make a Hacker News bot that looks for this phrase, waits 1 hour and sees if the comment is still downvoted.
Or, I'm going to write a copy and paste paragraph explaining to people why it appears that a comment has been downvoted. This would include all the mechanics, how karma works in HN, voting algorithms, mod flagging, time passed etc, involved as well as human psychology at play. So, the above phrase either is honest or dishonest.
For example, in this case I would posit that yes, you actually do know why they were being downvoted, but that by writing that you were actually saying "I disagree with the others who downvoted you". There is a difference.
It could be similiar to when people say "I don't know why anyone voted for Bush". They are not expressing ignorance about the reasons, they are saying that they disagree with peoples choices. In this case, it would be dishonest. Unless the person was actually ignorant of others (it is possible), in which case it is honest.
Off-topic, as mentioned.
Edits - I do know why I am being downvoted.
Oh wait...
In the Bush example, someone saying "I don't know why anyone voted for Bush" probably means "I don't really understand why (and with what thought process) anyone voted for Bush after everything we know about the matter."
In the recent GOP town hall, Cruz did not come across as supporting privacy or Apple at all. Rubio took the most measured stance and seemed at least to understand the issue the best. He did not support Apple, but said he understood that breaking into the phone would make it available to all and the government needs to work more closes with SV for a solution. Of course that could just mean PRISM V2.
Bernie has probably the strongest record, being both for net neutrality and against mass surveillance and the patriot act. I'd recommend taking a look through his policies as they are so well thought out in the cases he addresses. He doesn't address everything. On the other side of the fence, Rand Paul was the last sane voice (in terms of privacy), explicitly coming out in favor of net neutrality and strong, backdoor-less encryption.
This is in stark contrast to Clinton—well, just google "clinton privacy" and see the massive number of problems she's had to deal with that demonstrate her technological eagerness seems to outweigh her understanding. She's certainly been an eager advocate of EXACTLY the type of action we're seeing here, arguing that we need backdoors for law enforcement. Marco Rubio has explicitly advocated protecting the existing mass surveillance techniques.
I would be highly surprised if Trump or Cruz were for privacy—the former advocated for special ids, the latter doesn't seem to have a great grasp on technology, much less how to avoid using it to bludgeon people[1].
I very much doubt that any establishment-backed candidates in either of the establishment parties would be willing to make any public statements directly applicable to privacy. They are far more likely to come in soft from the other side, and chat up "tools to combat terrorism and other forms of extremism," while eliding over the implication that organized domestic protest groups like Black Lives Matter, Occupy Wherever, or "Y'All-Qaeda" militiamen would also be targeted, in addition to overseas groups.
I'd rather not elaborate further on anyone specific, as I don't want to shove my political biases down any throats on HN.
It's almost perfect isn't it ? It's prima facie reasonable, there's no immediate privacy violation, Apple - by the looks of it - could comply fairly trivially and failure is sure to lead to attempts to legislate. Don't like the motivation but you have give them points for planning and execution.
The FBI will gladly keep sealed its requests that Apple unlock phones in more ambiguous cases, because it would be easy for Apple to publicly refute. But this case is just too good for the people at the FBI who want keys to everyone's data.
The simplest explanation is that the FBI wants a legal precedent more than they want the information on the phone. If they get precedent they can request a "hack" into a phone whenever they feel the need, legally. The worry in this case is the troubling precedent it would set.
https://lawfareblog.com/not-slippery-slope-jump-cliff
Quotation from, Not a Slippery Slope, but a Jump off the Cliff By Nicholas Weaver.
The request to Apple is accurately paraphrased as "Create malcode designed to subvert security protections, with additional forensic protections, customized for a particular target's phone, cryptographically sign that malcode so the target's phone accepts it as legitimate, and run that customized version through the update mechanism". (I speak of malcode in the technical sense of "code designed to subvert a security protection or compromise the device", not in intent.)
The same logic behind what the FBI seeks could just as easily apply to a mandate forcing Microsoft, Google, Apple, and others to push malicious code to a device through automatic updates when the device isn't yet in law enforcement's hand. So the precedent the FBI seeks doesn't represent just "create and install malcode for this device in Law Enforcement possession" but rather "create and install malcode for this device".
Let us assume that the FBI wins in court and gains this precedent. This does indeed solve the "going dark" problem as now the FBI can go to Apple, Cisco, Microsoft, or Google with a warrant and say "push out an update to this target". Once the target's device starts running the FBI's update then encryption no longer matters, even the much stronger security present in the latest Apple devices. So as long as the FBI identifies the target's devices before arrest there is no problem with any encryption. But at what cost?
Or is that too tinfoil hat ?