Hacker News Reader

Comment by dcvuob | Hacker News Reader

Second example is very readable using Allman style:

    if( condition_a )
    {
         if( condition_b )
         {
             do_thing_a();
         } 
         else 
         {
             do_thing_b();
         }
    } 
    else 
    {
         do_something_else();
    }

Editor space is free, why not use it.

View on HN

Horizontal space is free, vertical space is not.

The more lines that are visible on your screen, the less you have to keep in your working memory. Human memory is fragile, so you really don't want to rely on it.

I can only fit 51 lines vertically (damn widescreen laptop) so that one snippet fills a good 1/3 of my screen.

Personally I'd write that as

    if (condition_a) {
        if (condition_b) do_thing_a();
        else do_thing_b();
    }
    else {
        do_something_else();
    }

The more lines that are visible on your screen, the less you have to keep in your working memory.

Sure if you only saw a few lines at a time, then this might be a problem. But you can see 51 on a laptop. This is enough for almost all cases. And you can scroll if you need to look up something. If you stumble upon a case of multiple if statement that span several screens then no style is going to help you see it in full. In that rare case you might see a little more, at the expense of all code ever becoming less readable (if we assume Allman is more readable for the sake of this argument of course).

If for some reason your code has more than, let's say >50% cases where something spans multiple screens and needs to be seen as a whole (code which should be refactored, but let's ignore that), then you might have an argument to use your style, in all other cases you're doing premature optimization of your coding style, so to speak.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com