Commuters Don't Stop Driving to Work Unless You Take Away Free Parking
citylab.com
citylab.com
Now, it just so happens that there's a Tri-Rail station right next to the building I work in, and I happen to live less than a mile from a Tri-Rail station. When when I ran the numbers a few years ago, it was still cheaper to drive than to ride the train (mainly because I work from home two days a week). It's not a time factor either---I drive during non-rush hour (a perk of being a programmer) and either way, it takes about the same time to drive as to take the train (I have taken the trip once or twice).
Now that gas prices have plummeted, even if I had to drive into the office five days a week, it would still be cheaper.
That said, there are people in the office that take the train, but they live further from the office than I do and for them, it is cost effective, even if they arrive late to the office about 10% of the time (mostly due to suicides and people stopping on the rails).
Public transportation is by design more inconvenient than taking the car because you have to wait for it and during rush hour be crammed in to a busy train.
However if the city has very good and fast public transportation it can still be better than driving the car and being stuck in traffic for hours.
London is a good example if public transportation done right. I can get anywhere by underground and bus way faster than you can with a car.
You can work in the train but not while driving.
Not all kind of work is done on a laptop or tablet. It can also be reading texts, checking emails etc. (of course you will try to optimize your schedule accordingly).
I recommend you get a reality check in the Tokyo metro at peak hour. Maybe you'll change your mind.
If you absolutely need a seat you can always let the first train got if there's no seats depends on haw important it is to get a seat for you.
Of course if you avoid peak hours which we can it's a different story.
I wonder if public transport would still be cheaper than having lots of cars if it were demanded to provide the same service : pick up anyone anywhere, including goods, and bring them to their destination, without having to change vehicles halfway.
The thing for me is, even with absurd levels of traffic, my car takes me to work in ~50 minutes, 20 minutes if there's no traffic. The only public transport option would do 1.5h, and would always do 1.5h (with regular delays to 2h I might add). Furthermore, I wouldn't be able to take much more than a laptop bag on public transport, whereas with my car I can do groceries on the way home.
And the only thing the government is talking about is making public transport more expensive.
i wish the people involved would take that challenge very seriously. :P
Which is a failure of policy in the Bay Area.
And people drive cars. So all cities are built for people. (Or did you think the cars drove around for fun on their own?)
The actual difference is they are simply very large cities. So they can afford transit that would be impossible in smaller cities.
You can not replicate what they do in other cities that are not as large (large measured in population density mainly).
There is nothing unique about their design other than being large. They have the same level of roads as any other city.
(And personally I have zero desire to walk anywhere, and I hate living in dense crowded cities. So I avoid living in - or even going to - cities that promote either of those things.)
Since I drive to the bus stop, I have my car available to get groceries, etc. And my employer picks up the tab for the monthly bus pass (they would also subsidize parking if I drove).
Seriously, the only drawback is that I have to be at the bus stop by a particular time since the buses don't run all day.
You nailed it! Removing parking from city centers to public transports hub, that can work. Where I live, around Geneva, depending on the direction you come from, switching from car to train/bus is either impossible or very expensive.
This city is broken on so many levels, completely outside of usual Swiss perfection, that it doesn't drown itself in the traffic every day only because it's tiny. Oh and the banks keep the treasury filled enough to maintain it (but not improve and any significant way)
I don't mind walking to the bus stop (that's probably good for me, anyways) but if I have to spend 2 hours commuting by public transit, as opposed to 15 in a car, that would be 3.5 hours wasted each day!
If the city started narrowing roads and selling off the land for development, just think how much money that would be worth. If road and rail got the same amount of public land devoted to them I'm pretty sure public transport would win.
For one, there are heavy negative externalities associated with cars. Governments choose to ignore those - and hence are in essence subsidising car users for free. If drivers actually had to pay the full cost of cars in terms of environment and health impact, they would be up in arms.
And of course there is infrastructure - car owners don't even cover a fraction of the actual cost of this - it all comes from general taxation.
So yes, we as a society have chosen to heavily subsidise car use, possibly for cultural or emotional reasons.
But ultimately, the piper will have to be paid. That's why I think we should all do our part to, as you say, encourage public transport use - and more walking/cycling.
My dream is that car usage might actually one day be charged at its true cost, instead of asking society to foot it's bill - but I think that's a long way off.
we all pay for it, and we all indirectly use it (how do you get groceries to your shop for example?), and most of us directly too.
"Moses’s parkways are also defined by ultra-low seemingly impenetrable bridges, designed, says Koppelman, to keep buses of poor city people out. Koppelman even once measured the overpasses on the Wantagh Parkway himself to verify that they were in fact deliberately built too low."
Robert Caro wrote an epic biography of the man with intense details of how he ticked.
The author literally spent decades studying the man and traced the arc of his life from his teenage years to political boss. It's pretty clear that the man was a racist, and personally drove publics works projects to keep races he disliked away from public parks, beaches and other things.
> measured the overpasses on the Wantagh Parkway himself to verify that they were in fact deliberately built too low
I'm questioning how the measurement of the bridge allows it to be determined if the bridge is deliberately, or accidentally too low, in the absence of other information. You're suggesting that there is copious other evidence that the bridge was deliberately too low, but that kind of proves my point. The measurement didn't show that it was deliberate - other evidence did instead.
But this is becoming a bit of a ridiculous conversation for such a trivial point. I was just pointing out that it was sloppy writing.
You then go and measure the bridge to verify the statements made by the person who built the bridge.
Read the book :D
The measuring doesn't verify the 'deliberate' claim, does it? It's only verifies the too low part. So
> measured the overpasses on the Wantagh Parkway himself to verify that they were in fact deliberately built too low
is nonsense. He measured the overpass to verify that it was too low. And he used statements from the person to verify the deliberate part. The measurement by itself doesn't prove the intent.
try no parking (really no parking, not just what people think of as "no" parking) and a congestion charge... and actually i would still drive if not for traffic. trains are rubbish.