Not merely courts.
Yes, I expect that courts would be tasked with drawing boundaries where extraordinary discretion is required. But throwing up your arms and saying "hey, we're the executive branch, not my problem" doesn't cut it. In fact that can very well land your ass in gaol or at the receiving end of a civil rights lawsuit (modulo limitations on liability for government officials, but that's another worm of cans).
Incidentally, I strongly recommend developing at least one or two abstract thinking skills if you're going to play around here. Helps smooth things along.
Relevant personal attributes, especially those which address credibility, are generally in bounds (see also "the asymmetry of bullshit", a/k/a Brandolino's law).
And observations of personal character not used as basis for argument aren't ad homs. Full stop.
http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/ad-hominem.html
If you're going to use logical fallacies, try to use them correctly.
And while the initial comment whose tone you disagreed with, and the paragraph above may not be seen as acceptable on HN (I tend to feel they skate within bounds), both point out a category of error, and steps a person might take to correct them. Insufficient abstract interpretation in the first case, incorrect use of specific terminology in this case.
Of course, you could simply insist on being wrong. But that's your call.
Cheers.
You can prove your point without being a dick, especially when being a dick does nothing to help prove your point. A little politeness goes a long way.
If this is your definition of "strictly following the law" imagine yourself in a scenario where the FBI brings a lawsuit against you: risk going to court, losing, and going to jail, or hiring a lawyer and fighting something with dubious constitution grounding.
There are so many different ways to lose when the FBI plays this game against private companies or individual. They sue you because they want to put you in jail, not clarify the law.
If you're a strongly opinionated CEO of a company with a war chest you fight it and at the very least stay out of jail. If you're the CEO of a small ISP/web hosting company you suck it up, do what they say, and follow the gag order.
I do agree it's not quite fair to put defense costs on the company/individual that needs to fight it, but the alternative I can think of is a public defender type system that I don't think many people would be happy with for corporations.
Isn't that what we expect from all people and institutions? moreover, we expect the people to be in control of "challenges" to the laws, and the laws themselves. Much of what's wrong with government comes from government creating self-serving laws.
The laws are what the courts interpret them to be; no more and no less. Like it or not, strict interpretation is a fantasy and has been since the late 1700s.