Ask HN: Are there any 'honest' crowd funding sites?
So are there any other good crowdfunding sites that I can confidently contribute on?
So are there any other good crowdfunding sites that I can confidently contribute on?
I'd be very cautious about hardware on these sites. Don't donate money that you can't stand to lose.
I don't agree that refunds should be required in all cases. If a company legitimately raises money to produce a product and in the end that product fails to be delivered, that is a risk you made as an "early investor" to contribute. Like the stock exchange, or any investment product, there is no guarantee you will get your money back or see a return on that money.
In the end it doesn't take but 5-10 minutes of your time to do some basic due diligence and make a determination if you want to invest or not. Look at who is behind the project, are they open about who they are and their backgrounds. Look at the product itself, is it to good to be true. Look at the time and updates, are they updating regularly and have they described the product in detail. Look at the rewards, are they legitimate and doable, or are they too good to be true as well. That all falls on you, and you can't expect the site to know whether a product will succeed or not ahead of time.
With that said, I do think the sites could offer an additional level of "identity verification" to potential investors. Where campaign could agree to a slightly higher fee to undergo a background check or verified identity. That itself would be useful and I think would instill trust. However, there's a fine line there in that it could push people to not invest in campaigns where the identity has not been verified. Maybe have different levels of verification at different price points.
Not everybody does their research, a 'honest' site has a moral obligation to protect its users. In the age when even free browsers give out warnings against phishing sites to protect their users, is it too much to ask them to block far fetched projects like the dragon fly?
It really comes down to what risk you are willing to take. Because someone doesn't want to do their research, that is not the site's fault at all. In fact the site is very clear that you should do your own research and that there is risk (https://www.kickstarter.com/trust). There is an enormous difference between a browser determining a site is a phishing site vs whether a product that has yet to be made will be a success. Maybe these sites aren't for you and the risk level you are willing to take, there is nothing wrong with that and I am not knocking you for it, but that's not the site's fault.