It's great until the lowest common denominator finds it then it goes to crap.
Reddit is only spared because you can unsubscribe from default subreddit's and find more niche sub-reddit's that attract a niche audience or subset of users that are less likely to "sh#tpost" for lack of a better term. Not to say all new users are bad or don't contribute anything new, but the noise to signal ratio is way worse the more people pile on and start becoming an echo chamber. I've even seen it a little with HN as its gained popularity, but thankfully this site is so niche its not too bad.
But I kind of wish I could do that with other community sites and social media. I know a lot of people loved twitter, or digg, or whatever back in the day before the celebrities, media, and extended relatives caught on.