What is the correct amount of fuel used to make the landing attempt? I just googled and didn't quickly find it, though I did find this speculation at StackExchange[0] talking about reserving 15% of the fuel, or 66 tons, for the landing. 66 tons is 132,000 pounds, so 100,000 pounds seems a reasonable rounding - what am I missing? (I don't know anything about rockets.)
[0] http://space.stackexchange.com/questions/4466/how-is-spacex-...
The amount of fuel used varies a lot, because they can land in different places. At one extreme, you have a landing at the launch site, which uses the most fuel in order to get the first stage turned around and coming back. Barge landings use less fuel, because they can be positioned under the flight path so the rocket doesn't have to maneuver as much.
SES-9 was at the other extreme. It reserved the bare minimum of fuel for the landing attempt because of its heavy, high-performance payload. That meant no maneuvering boostback burn, no or minimal reentry burn, and the landing burn itself was done with three engines instead of the typical one. That saves fuel because the rocket decelerates faster and spends less time fighting gravity, but of course the control challenge is magnified, which is probably why it went all explodey.
Putting some numbers on it, I found some estimates here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/spacex/comments/2vuy1v/how_much_fue...
According to that, landing at the launch site would require about 38 tons of fuel, and a (normal) barge landing would require about 20 tons. SES-9's barge landing would have been even less.
I believe the 15% from your StackExchange link is confused, and someone mistook the payload penalty (about 15% for a barge landing) for the amount of fuel required.
In any case, the fuel is cheap relative to everything else so as long as they can put the payload on orbit expending almost any amount of fuel to recover the rocket is perfectly reasonable. Not sure why the ULA guy thought spending 100,000 of fuel to recover a 15 million dollar core would be a bad thing.
And yeah, even if it was 100,000 pounds, what's the point?
You heard the candid opinion of a man at a given point of time. It doesn't mean he's unsuitable for his position.
What makes him unsuitable for his position is that he thought he could discuss it with students.
The tenor and his thoughts I've heard from all sorts of businesses with relevant detail in their fields. This is an accurate portrayal of all of those conversations.
Being wrong is a constant in complex situations, and what matters is correcting and moving on.
If we take just the last year, I've been wrong a breathtaking amount of time, as has everyone else I've ever discussed with. It happens, and you're constantly trying to move yourself closer to truth.