Consumption stats show the gap between rich and poor is less than most assume
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
Granting that it seems pretty rational to just settle with the four-times pricier television and leave the rest to the grandchildren or charity.
There are of course exceptions, e.g. someone really should have talked to Mike Tyson about the diminishing marginal utility of Bengal tigers.
It effectively says that the poor are spending (ie, consuming) more than they make to maintain their standard of living. So, yes, consumption is the same, but the cost is a mortgaged future or a edifice that crumbles the first time anyone is seriously sick.
Further, it seems strange that the values are absolute. I'd like to see them as a percentage of income.
http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=p-dY8J8J_WREnyO8P_QLq...
Interesting point: the lowest fifth use 60% of their post-tax income for housing. Add in food, and you're up to 95%.
Add together the trio of "food, shelter and clothing" and you're over their income.
1.) If rich people spend as much as poor people, then their happiness must be equal because the excess income from the rich go into silly things like investments and retirement savings.
Spending $30K a year and knowing your nest egg grew by $100K, and spending $30K a year without health insurance living paycheck to paycheck in fear of layoffs isn't exactly equal happiness.
2.) A family of 2 must spend 2X to be just as happy as a family of 1 spending X.
At the very least, the Costco / BJs / Sam's Wholesale factor debunks that assumption.
I'd model happiness in discrete buckets: "can retire", "can last a while without a job", "must keep working to maintain lifestyle", and "must keep working or risk pain and death" At the high end there might also be "looking for ways to blow the money before getting too old"
The world, especially the Muslim part, seems to object.
We haven't freed them from whatever despot got to them first, but they don't seem to value that all that much. It's hard to see how their choice or situation is our fault.
Although it would be nice if this were the case, history starkly disagrees.
Does "history" think that we have freed them from despotism? Does history think that they'd like us to do something about their despot?
If so, history seems to have some problems with reality.
But I take it that what this article is really arguing for is the maintenance of free trade. And on that point I agree.
The NYTimes article is guilty of the same thing.
Since this is a study about spending habits, it is an incredibly misleading way to present the statistics. Not only does it hide the behavior of the very top but it skews the results of the rest of the upper fifth (the top 18%-19%).