U.S. government sets record for failures to find files when asked
hosted.ap.org
hosted.ap.org
It isn't as if he gets to decide what is released and what isn't. Some functionary is making that determination and likely going the safe route each time. Even if he did make a decision prior agreements with others can put a block in.
BTW, a wonderful site http://www.foia.gov/data.html
I just wish people had long term memory, so they'd stop serving as enabling patsies.
At the same time, he doesn't seem to have his facts straight about a lot of important things.
One picture of Trump that emerges is: strong-armed CEO surrounded by yes-men and sycophants. He's used to going unquestioned. He's used to "being right" just because people around him affirm his statements without questioning them.
He seems to live in a fact-bubble of his own creation. But because it's different (and to many Republicans and a few others, more appealing) than the fact-bubble around Washington, he polls well.
But what's actually going to happen if he gets elected?
"The most transparent administration in history."
Here, 77% sounds like a large number because it is a clear majority of the total. Here, the implicit baseline is 100%, which makes it sound terrible. However, at least in my field of laser-plasma interaction, an energy conversion efficiency of an interaction of 5% is a lot compared to the typical interaction! That is, if you lose 95% of the energy you put into the system, that's much better than most experiments! The baseline here cannot be 100%, it has to be the efficiency of the typical experiment.
It would help if media learn that whenever it reports a statistic or a measurement, it needs to communicate a scale, a baseline, something for comparison. There are times, would you believe it, when 100% isn't the right baseline or the number of fingers on one's hand isn't a useful scale. (1000 people are many compared to my number of close friends but small compared to the US population). Because otherwise, people can get the wrong impression by comparing a naked number to implicit, and meaningless, baselines.
If you look at news reports at the federal, state, local levels of government from 1990 to today, you'll see that quotes that would come from a local official in command in 1990 are now issued from a PR flack at HQ. I witnessed one example first hand where a school principal, terrified of being quoted about a book sale, frantically directed a person who turned out to be a reporter to the school district public affairs officer.
FOIA is similar -- these searches used to be distributed but in many cases are now all conducted by counsel at HQ, and they limit the scope of their search to the official repositories that may or may not be relevant.
If you want actual information from a FOIA process, focus your search on email, which is usually centralized, and jump off on addition requests from there.
There are three main problems with the way FOIA requests are fulfilled. 1) They are incredibly time consuming to do properly, 2) Very few additional resources are given in order to alleviate the time consuming process, and 3) the process for tasking and responding to requests is grossly inefficient. The requests are literally sent out via e-mail and responses back are sent via e-mail attachment.
To paint the picture a little more clearly, let's say someone submits a FOIA request for all records related to the "Boston Bombing". For a broad search like that, hundreds if not thousands of people will be searching through their records. Those hundreds/thousands of people each find five documents which they have to send back to the agency's FOIA office via e-mail attachments. Most of the records are duplicates (e.g., an e-mail sent out to a distribution list), but everyone still has to send their record in. Let's just say it is a very frustrating process for everyone involved.
I hope it doesn't sound as though I am making excuses - quite the opposite. Merely pointing out that while there are definitely issues that affect accuracy, they might not be the issues everyone assumes.
Perhaps this is a sector that is in need of some innovation/disruption =).
One explanation is that the administration is being dishonest. Another is that the administration is just inefficient, sloppy and slow at handling these kinds of requests.
Obama has taken a "civil rights action hero" approach to being president.
A different president might have taken an "efficient administrator and process reformer emphasizing high quality service" approach to being president. But that sounds pretty boring.
Which hints at a profound lack of preparation on their part. Basically, they act like a company that when asked before a merger to provide their paperwork for due dilligance answers "Um, oh .. eh .. we didn't think that you need this. We will go and find all that we need and then get back to you, okay?" with the difference that the company in question has a real incentive to get all the papers, but still could have avoided this situation if their initial "paper creation" process included "archive papers so that they can be retrieved without hassle"
I wonder if forcing/automating such an archiving at creation/update of documentation could solve this problem.
Also sounds a lot closer to what the job of an executive really is.
But being more open-minded to releasing machine-readable data and responding to FOIAs are a different thing...just as Obama can make an argument that he's been very pro-civil-liberties, and yet his administration has prosecuted more federal whistleblowers than all other administrations combined [3].
Maybe I missed it...but it seems like the AP goes out of its way to avoid any use of percentages for comparison between administrations...Maybe this was not tracked in the same way during the Bush administration? That said, I wouldn't be surprised if Obama led in both raw numbers and percentages of denials. Though it's still difficult to know how apples to apples that is.
I had to Google around quite a bit to find any reference to Bush numbers...here's an old AP article I found linked to from an old Slashdot thread [4]:
> - In all, the agencies reviewed by the AP reported getting 444,924 FOIA requests in fiscal 2009, compared with 493,610 in fiscal 2008. Besides those cases, they started each year with FOIA requests pending: 145,162 as the 2009 budget year began last October; 156,611 as the 2008 fiscal period started.
> - The agencies processed 501,158 FOIA requests in the 2009 period, compared with 504,110 the previous year.
> Much of the Obama administration’s early effort on FOIA seems to have been aimed at clearing out the backlog of old cases: The number of requests still sitting around past the time limits spelled out in the open-records law fell from 124,019 in budget year 2008 to 67,764 at the end of the most recent budget year over the 17 agencies, the AP’s review found
> - The agencies reviewed provided everything sought in FOIA requests in at least 162,205 cases last fiscal year, compared with 196,776 the previous year.
> - They denied FOIA requests in their entirety based on exemptions 20,005 times last fiscal year, compared with 21,057 times the previous year.
[0] https://www.propublica.org/article/has-obama-kept-his-open-g...
[0a] https://www.propublica.org/article/trying-to-get-records-fro...
[1] https://open.whitehouse.gov/browse
[2] https://sunlightfoundation.com/blog/2014/08/05/now-its-easie...
[3] http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/jan/10/...
[4] http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/politics/ap-analysi...
(Submitted title was "Obama's Lack of Transprency: Censored or Denied 77% of FOIA Requests".)
I found an amusing response to a request like that here: http://www.mackinac.org/media/images/2009/7FOIAb.jpg
To me, that's a reasonable response to an overly broad request.
State agencies, especially police agencies, are laser focused on external funding sources and track federal grant monies very carefully. Likewise, the Feds require exacting tracking of assets purchased.
Usually there is an office of 6-12 people dedicated to those grants.
Broadness of Scope is the Only way to deal with Agencies attempting to obfuscate data and documents.
--tyingq: My Apologies if it was not you, I'd be interested in knowing how people believe pertinent documents can be researched if not for a broad net of related documents, when the succinct question to be asked is unable to be known due to completely hidden documents and "missing information"
I did not downvote. In fact, I don't think you can downvote direct responses to your own comments, can you?
Edit:
>> I'd be interested in knowing how people believe pertinent documents can be researched if not for a broad net of related documents
Well, there's broad (90,000 documents, your example) and really broad (2 million documents, my example).