It's only a poor choice if there's anything worth securing on the phone, and most people think that there's not, he destroyed his personal phone while leaving this phone intact.
In any case, most people unlock their phone dozens of times a day, perhaps hundreds of times a day (for some). So expecting users to use a secure passphrase as an unlock code is unreasonable. It seems that it would be better to have a 2 stage system -- if the phone hasn't been unlocked with the passcode in X hours (user configurable), then it has to be unlocked with the secure passphrase -- even if someone knows the passcode the phone can't be unlocked with it after that timer expires. And on reboot, only the passphrase should be accepted.
So someone that unlocks their phone frequently can use a simple passcode, but once the phone has been out of their possession for a few hours, only the passphrase can unlock it.