How do we win in Iraq? We supported the Shia backed government and they used their power to oppress Sunni political opponents. Now the Sunni regions are in revolt with ISIS ruling large swathes on the ground and the Iraqi government is incapable of stopping them even with support from Iran. I saw first hand SF officers having to deal with political target packs from the Iraqi government while our senior military leaders would turn a blind eye.
How do we win in Afghanistan? The place seems more tribal than Iraq. Do we stop the drug trade or support it? We can’t seem to figure that out ourselves. We payed ex-DEA agents outrageous money to run around and destroy poppy fields while Marines I know where happy to ignore the fields if the tribal leaders stopped the roadside bombs. If we can’t figure out our own objectives how can we ever ‘win’.
Personally, I’m all for using SF/Airpower to help a side we believe to be the best and letting the naturally lines form: Shia, Sunni, Kurd, etc. The region is beset with fake boundaries dictated by foreign powers and our foray hasn’t helped. We can’t allow ISIS to exist, but ground troops aren’t the answer. I’d begin by funding all limited wars through SOCOM, otherwise big military will stomp-in, take as much money as it can, and create havoc. Let the units trained in FID working with the locals dictate the support assets they need.
And I’d hardly say we conducted these wars on the cheap. Could have been a lot cheaper regarding money if big military had stayed out and we focused only on routing out Al-Qaeda and not on some fantasy of nation building. And cheap regarding KIAs, well I’m glad about that one since more people killed doesn’t necessarily mean a better outcome. I don’t believe more troops, more force, and more governance imposed by an external entity would have solved the problems of either Iraq or Afghanistan. The problem wasn’t a lack of political will but a lack of political reality and an inability to actually figure out realistic goals that could be accomplished based upon the situation on the ground and the assets we have as a country.