Call me naive, but I always put human lives as a first key to judging the success of any such "operation". Death, torture and general misery do not constitute a part of any solution. Specially when the solution is not a solution begin with.
It does, but it is quite rare to see it executed without some hidden agenda. I can think of very few instances where this was done cleanly.
The concept has been abused and will no doubt be continued to be abused. It's very important to fight against such abuse. Nevertheless I think that the fundamental idea behind it is a good one.