That's true, but they don't calculate a number about my creditworthiness. It's the number that would be the problem.
If the agencies only passed information on I could see them maybe being allowed to pass, but since they calculate a number, they are now presenting new, inaccurate, information. They have a responsibility to verify the accuracy of their data if they are going to create new data from it.
Please cite the legal statute indicating this.
You can't just throw the word "responsibility" into the air and expect people to take it at fact value. In fact, they have no legal responsibility to verify any of the data they receive from anyone. Consumers have multiple opportunities to dispute invalid items on their credit:
1. Free credit reports from all major reporting agencies once a year from annualcreditreport.com
2. The same credit reports more often for a fee
3. At any point where they are denied financing due to negative items on their credit report, regardless of the last time they accessed their free report
Their responsibility is to their paying client, the lender, not you. I'm sure the lender would have a civil case if they were getting a lot of false reports and it was causing damages to their bottom line in missed loan opportunities.
Google functions as an index that points you to another source. They don't actually have control over the source.
The credit bureaus are the source.
At least that's what they claim.